And everyone who went to catholic school is basically “well I’m not a catholic but [hour long discussion on the corporal works of mercy]”
I thought the guy telling you to give food to the poor was Jesus.
Doncha know, that Jesus fella chose the dumbest loudest asshole among his disciples to stand in between man and Jesus and sit on a throne and tell us we’re going to hell! Try to keep up!
I don’t think so, because Jesus was jew and the text states it’s talking about a catholic person.
Catholics follow the teachings of Jesus. It’s a Christian religion.
Yes, but only for the purposes of conversion. Otherwise they don’t get food.
Yeah, that’s not what Jesus said at al.
Because the converts are those who found evengicalism to be not legalistic enough. They’re not good people
I really hope the “catholic church is progressive” discourse can die now.
Edit: for your information: the pope recently came out and said marriage is only between a man and a woman and all that jazz and apparently it took a lot of people by surprise
This is not defending them, because the Catholic church has never been progressive. However, there’s a difference between a marriage in law and in the church. The church probably doesn’t recognize any marriage that it didn’t endorse, but it doesn’t make you not married. The church saying “we won’t marry you” isn’t the same as them saying “the state should not allow you to marry.” I have no idea on the modern church’s stance on the latter.
Legalism is the biblical definition of the devil.
Yea, cool, we understand all that but still fuck the church and their archaic definitions of marriage. Plain as.
And the modern stance is the same as it’s always been. The church has never let up on trying to interfere with state matter, trying to ban LGBT from being legally married.
If all-powerful omnipotent God has such an issue with queers he should stop making them. And if he can’t stop queer people from existing then he isn’t all-powerful and we don’t have to fucking listen to his dumb ass.
Jesus is pan because he loves everybody. Also a commie, he want to feed the poor people.
In starting a new church. Its Christianity but communist and gay. Fight me evangelicals. Gay Jesus says its okay to beat you with a stick like the peddlers at the temple of Jerusalem.
We will be having our first sermons shortly, everybody welcome. Bigots included. They’re welcome to come get beaten with a stick.
He was also trans because he was conceived through parthenogenesis, therefore no Y chromosome.
Let Gay Jesus into your hearts today and let us share everything in common, to each according to their needs!
I’m not a religious person at all but I can let your church be with no issues. All good here !
God gives you the freedom to sin so that you can choose virtue, or something like that
Even though it already supposedly knew what your choice would be because it is claimed to be an omnipotent being.
When you break theology down into its logical points the entire thing is just a mess of contradictions.
Nah they gave us the ability to sin cause they a freak like us. God invented eating ass
Or as Eve likes to call it, eating the forbidden fruit
Catholics, as people from any other religion, only appear tolerant, progressive, or accepting where they’re a minority, because the people that accepts them are the progressive and tolerant. Wherever they’re the majority they show their true face. That’s why that image about the catholic church is projected mainly from America/the Anglosphere, ask about how progressive it is to someone from Poland, Italy, or Spain and you’ll have a very different answer.
The Catholic church is a lot of things. Going from writing Rerum Novarum, calling for essentially dramatic limits put on capitalism to curb wealth inequality and put the responsibility of societal wellbeing on the wealthy, and Sicut Dudum, calling for the release of the enslaved people of the Canary Islands and to give them the opportunity to willingly be baptized instead of theough deception and force, which in 1435 is wildly progressive of a stance to take, and Pacem in Terris calling for nuclear disarmament to Magnificas Humanitas calling for limits on AI.
Then theres the crusades and the centuries of European kingmaking and mediating treaties that all collapsed in and resulted in all the wars in Europe for over a millennium up to and including WW1 and in the present day the rampant pedophilia problem to holding generally anti-gay stances.
Sometimes its kinda progressive, sometimes its wildly conservative. Gun to head, forced to choose some flavor of Christianity, I’d rather go with the Catholics than any of the American Evangelical Protestant denominations. The pedo shit is still pedo shit but that’s not unique to Catholicism, that’s “an institution with power attracting predators” problem and there is a lot of unaccounted for history that they are responsible for.
True, but gun to my head I guess I’m either episcopal or quaker
Going from writing Rerum Novarum, calling for essentially dramatic limits put on capitalism to curb wealth inequality and put the responsibility of societal wellbeing on the wealthy
That’s just what they write? What do they actually do? Significantly, most of the main areas of catholicism, like latin america and the Philipines are extremely unequal if anything. I read a study (which I can’t find, so feel free to disbelieve me) that said that hierchial religions, like catholicism, correlates with inequality.
Sicut Dudum, calling for the release of the enslaved people of the Canary Islands and to give them the opportunity to willingly be baptized instead of theough deception and force, which in 1435 is wildly progressive of a stance to take
Catholicism would later approve of and facilitate slavery in countless other regions, like in the Americas, or approve of the trade of African slaves. Often, they were more brutal in their methods than the Spanish army, or Spanish civilian settlements. Besides, what did that “willingly baptized” even entail, considering that the canary religion is gone now.
The Catholic Welfare Council, along with Dorothy Day and the Catholic Workers Movement, pushed for socialism hard in the US back in the 1920s-1940s.
Piux XI spoke out heavily against Nazism and the dangers of fascism in the world. While his successor, Pius XII, took a more diplomatic stance publicly, he privately worked with local churches and religious leaders to move hundreds of thousands if not millions of Jews out of Europe during the war.
Today, Catholic Charities is the largest sponsor of foreign refugees. Millions are in the US thanks to them.
Not saying the Church is great but they usually do practice what they preach.
Thats why I said Catholicism is a mixed bag of moderately progressive and quite conservative stances. Being one of, if not, the most powerful organization in the world, even just paying lipservice to an issue does cause changes to happen. Yeah in the modern day, the catholic church doesn’t wield the same political authority it did during the height of the Middle Ages, so lipservice from them doesnt go nearly as far as it used to.
Its why I tempered my vaguely positive comments about catholicism with pointing out its history of being pretty central to the centuries of conflict in Europe and in the middle east and the current pedophile problem that it refuses to deal with.
Vehemently, fuck the catholic church because they attract and harbor pedophiles, fuck them for their centuries of political meddling, fuck them for the crusades. But I also recognize the catholic church isnt going anywhere so I’ll do the practical thing and praise the good done and condemn the evils perpetuated.
Even with all these problems, the catholic church is still a generally better organization that the various evangelical protestant offshoots.
Even with all these problems, the catholic church is still a generally better organization that the various evangelical protestant offshoots.
I mean if the best argument you have is that “it isn’t the absolute worst option” then you have a pretty flimsy argument. The lesser evil is still fucking evil and should be treated as such.
There is nothing practical about sane washing something that is intrinsically terrible just because it is relatively better than something else.
Agreed. A terrible history but the most stable now. If you have to go Christian, it’s the best option.
Is it? Like, I love rituals, they’re part of why I’m pagan, so I’d go episcopal if I went Christian. Otherwise there’s the Quakers who’ve usually been the goid guys
if you have to go Christian
That’s the thing, no one has to be religious. We have the option to abandon these archaic, nonsensical beliefs.
I’m an atheist. It was meant rhetorically.
Has the catholic church ever once supported same-sex marriage? My understanding is that they’ve been pretty clear on the subject for hundreds of years, not sure why anyone would be surprised by this position they’re taking. “New pope who dis” doesn’t seem like a good enough foundation to get one’s hopes up for the catholic church to suddenly pivot to being progressive.
No they haven’t approved gay marriage, they do approve blessings to gay couples. It’s a start.
Not on team Catholic myself, but the situation is interesting and complicated. The Catholic church is much more like a conglomerate than it is an organisation. Part of that is the real potential for a schism. If that happens, the political power the Vatican has over more radical and potential harmful parts of the church is gone. Unfortunately that means very real harm could result from their approval of gay marriage.
I get the impression that moving policy in a system like that takes a lot of time, and delicate movement. It definitely sucks, but I can also understand the situation.
They obviously approve of gay unions when one party is too young to consent
I really hope the “catholic church is progressive” discourse can die now.
I’ve always assured it’s a relative thing rather than an absolute, compared to the Taliban or WestBro Baptism they are. It’s similarly the case with politics, like people saying the Democrats are left is relative to the position of the GOP, not an absolute when analyzing their policies.
Yes, and that kind of arbitrary relativity discourse needs to die.
I don’t know why it’d take anyone by surprise. Catholic marriage isn’t the same as civil marriage. Divorced people can’t get married in the church either.
That doesn’t mean gay Catholics can’t get married, just that they can’t receive the sacrament of marriage in the church.
It depends on your frame of reference. The Catholic Church is quite progressive compared to other religions, or the christo-fascist sects. It’s less progressive than a handful of other sects. Compared to modern progressive platforms in pretty much any country, it’s not progressive. For a conservative institution, it’s shown the ability to change more so than others.
No one cares about how it compares to other religions. That’s entirely irrelevant to the fact that the Catholic church is not a progressive institution.
Using relativity to bend the argument is just making excuses for it and completely misses the point.
It’s all relative though, there’s not an absolute goodness scale.
We aren’t talking about arbitrary “goodness” or morality. We are talking about political leanings. Don’t naively conflate the two.
He also said any priests who report child rapists would be excommunicated.
He doesn’t support breaking the confessional seal, which isn’t really that controversial as far as professions with similar protection. They could still encourage them to turn themselves into the authorities.
It’s really not any different than other privileged conversations. Lawyers are generally not a must report, but may report about future crimes. Doctors generally are in a similar situation where they must believe there is imminent danger to people.
Professionals with similar protections have mandatory reporting duties when it comes to child rape.
How do you say that and not get ousted? I can’t imagine any phrasing that doesn’t feel deeply suspicious.
I mean, because that’s been the Catholic policy the whole time.
Presumably the issue is reporting stuff they learn in confessions, which I mean you can see where he’s coming from.
I mean you can see where he’s coming from.
So my parents should have converted to Catholicism before abusing me, causing me lifelong mental (and probably physical) issues because that would apparently make it OK? They could’ve confessed and been fine and not had to face any consequences despite child abuse being ongoing? They’re just fine to let a child continuing to experience things with lifelong consequences?
So my parents should have converted to Catholicism before abusing me, causing me lifelong mental (and probably physical) issues because that would apparently make it OK?
I mean no? But if Catholic!your parents knew they’d get reported if they confessed they most likely just wouldn’t confess so it’s a wash anyway. To be clear though I think they should report this stuff, but there is a good faith argument for not doing so is my point.
I don’t get the good-faith argument. So if I start a religion and declare that confessions are a deeply-held, critical part of the religion, I suddenly have an argument to not report people doing terrible things?
If the people come confess stuff to you on the basis of this part of your religion, and you assure them that you won’t report whatever they say, yeah pretty much. The utilitarian logic is important here; nobody would report this stuff if there were consequences for doing so.
Do you perhaps have a source on this?
I would imagine that Leo would adopt the church’s position: priests can generally report crimes they become aware of, except by hearing confessions. The penalty for breaking the seal of the confessional is excommunication latae sententiae.
To most rational people, there is no distinction.
Any organization that forbids you from turning in criminal reprobates because of sacred right is at odds with civilization.
Therapists are not allowed to report past crimes their client admits to (without consent) over here.
Doctor-patient confidentiality does not rank lower than the prosecution of past crimes.
Same with lawyers and a bunch of other professions.
So youre not really wrong about the catholic church forbidding priests from divulging what they learn in confession to the police, but the work around for that (that really only works for true believers) is that in order to receive divine absolution from god, part of the penance of confession is typically to turn yourself in to the authorities. If a criminal is going to Confession and is admitting crimes to a priest they on some level are probably actually bought in on the “god absolves your sins if you actually perform your penance as instructed” mythology.
Legality ≠ Morality. Penance is usually different for each person
Source?
There was a news article about it not long after he was elected.
The is such a thing as liberation theology.
But doctor, I AM the lamb of god!
The Archon of Istanbul was Archon of Constantinople
Now it’s Archon of Istanbul not Archon of Constantinople
Why did Constantinople get the works?
Mustn’t ask us; not its business.
Every woman in Constantinople, actually resides in Istanbul, and has never resided in Constantinople.
Then you read the Epistle, and it does not say that at all.
Almost like conservatives thrive on misinformation
Catholics just wants humanity to end.
No that’s Evangelicals.
To be fair, the end game for all Christians Catholic or otherwise is the return of Jesus and the beginning of Armageddon. That’s like, the primary prophecy of Christianity.
Word.
Yes but no, Catholics are generally bought in on the “only Jesus/God know when the second coming is happening, its our duty to be good people and ready for it” of the prophesy and typically arent dominionists actively trying to fulfill the prophesy of Revelations and force YHWH’s hand into the second coming.
Now that I’ve said something nice about the catholic church, it has a wildly rampant pedophile problem and actively covers it up instead of bringing monsters in their ranks to justice.
Pedophilia has been a major recruitment path for the priesthood for centuries. It probably accounts for 20% of their ranks. They can’t reject a strategy that is that successful, what else do they have? Celibacy has never been a big draw.
deleted by creator















