It pisses me off that AI has almost certainly just scraped the self-owned store without permission
The first sentence of those terms of service is way worse, because it gives Etsy a perpetual license to your content. In fact, they didn’t even need to include the sentence about the fact they’d use your content to train AI – once the content is theirs, they can do anything with it.
Like hire 3rd parties in other countries to recreate best selling products? And then just replace them small businesses with look-alike small businesses, but all the profit is theirs?
Evil genius.
I think Amazon has a patent on that business model.
And with this you got a place in my Bookmarks and my Obsidian Vault for future shopping!
This post itself sounds like ChatGPT, for example ‘that’s not an accusation, that’s the business model’ and ‘legally, it may change nothing, emotionally, it totally did’.
I wish Etsy could be less terrible. They already turned away a lot of shops (and consumers) when they let in everything that was customisable, even if it was cheap crap that wasn’t homemade. The artist that I commission closed her shop there long ago. After finally trying to recover some of their bad reputation and have some restrictions, they just decide to kill it again. Like damn, I used to love Etsy.
I’m too broke to close my store, that $100 ish monthly extra income really helps me reach the end of the month.
I can’t close it.
The AI hater in me wants Etsy to fail because of it. But that means I’m going back to beans and rice for most meals
Then don’t close your store. But maybe look at other options you can open an account or store on instead. Put more effort into the other platforms than you do on updating etsy. Over time you may find it’s better having multiple ways to sell. Etsy will also be less relevant as you sue their competitors. Their only advantage now is they are where everyone else is. Just like Facebook or WhatsApp etc. You don’t have to go cold turkey. Just use the alternatives.
We need a Diaspora solution for independent sellers. Or a fediverse-like thing. No “Lord of the Rings” central management thing.
I solved this problem by just writing my own store and slapping it on a web host. The good news is that I control it, but the bad news is that its discoverability is crap. I guess part of the appeal with Etsy and its ilk is that they’re also a directory service for sellers. Or, well, they were before all of Etsy devolved into being Aliexpress with extra steps. (Seriously, the amount of drop shipped commodity OEM Chinese garbage on there is unreal.)
(Seriously, the amount of drop shipped commodity OEM Chinese garbage on there is unreal.)
I recently visited etsy and hadn’t been there in a few years. This was spot on. I was looking for something niche and i found 2 dozen listings all showing the same 3 variations of the item for $30+. i go to aliexpress and find each of those 3 variations for $3-5.
I used to like shopping hand crafted things from there but don’t plan on visiting it again any time soon/ever
deleted by creator
Cool which payment platform isnt owned by fascists? Please enlighten us. Can you offer a single alternative?
deleted by creator
Why won’t you give us an alternative
deleted by creator
Your original comment implies there are shopping platforms that aren’t fascist. Unless you’re just saying words recreationally for no reason?
I wonder what you were like before you became like this
Whataboutism would require avoidiance of answering whether the initial proposal has validity, pretty sure the lad is including Shopify in that claim.
deleted by creator
Check out who owns every credit company and bank.
Shopify, Stripe, Paypal… Are there any that are not owned, founded, or largely involved with fascist billionaires?
Are there any that aren’t? Tech bros are pretty much exclusively the ones that own that kind of service. And we’ve all watched them all be fascists for quite a while now.
There’s a zillion self hostable shop platforms. Product pages, shopping cart, etc. Payments are harder.
I feel like it might be asking a bit much tech-wise for a small business to go that far lol. They sell hats and bags and stuff. It’s not their fault almost every tech company they could possibly interact with is evil
I mean that’s every bank and credit card, too.
Their self-owned shop? Or do you mean one of the payment options?
deleted by creator
Which platform?
My partner by no means has a big shop of Etsy, but got a few sales every month. She also removed everything and deleted her account.
I thought Etsy was a B-Corp, but apparently they let that lapse in 2017. TIL.
They are whatever the opposite of a b corp is
Yeah, I keep getting emails telling me I belong to AI just about every other day. A new terms of service a day. Was it update ToS month or something and fuck over the living? A telecommunications I use… Dropbox… Viki Rakuten… Chewy… CVS… Robinhood. All since September and I’m probably missing some. Etsy of course eBay too.
Yep. It’s what tbis AI rush is actually about, I think.
Colonising (our) information and owning it, turning the rest of us into serfs in an information ecosystem we made.
And not just owning the platform and access to it and having editorial influence. Owning information itself.
Dystopian as fuck, and the thing we should all be focusing on.
The irony of writing that post with AI… they couldn’t write it in their own words but had to use claude for it?
do you have a base for that accusation?
Thats not an accusation, thats the business model
So we deleted everything. Every product, Every photo. Legally, that may change nothing. Emotionally, it did.
Both of these are pure LLMisms. If you told claude your story and asked it to make a infographic picture to share on social media you would get really similar writing.
I use AI a lot at work and have a hypersensitive sense for it. Everyone in this community is LLM-deaf because the majority of members don’t use it enough to recognize it’s default voice in something.
The top and bottom paragraph might be their own words its too short for me to tell.
It leads to hilarious situations like this where users unironically share LLM generated content (in part or in whole) and when I point it out I get downvote bombed. It’s doubly ironic when users shame me for calling it out to protect the AI…
So sometimes I’ll argue with users here with claude on default settings, specifically prompting it to be obvious that it’s claude but not too obvious. I’ve never been called on it.
There’s also this:
People who frequently use ChatGPT for writing tasks are accurate and robust detectors of AI-generated text (Russell et al., ACL 2025)
In Russel et al’s study just 5 “expert” users of AI could predict AI generated text with a majority vote. They had a 299/300 accuracy far exceeding existing AI detectors or the general public.
There are also studies showing if you don’t use AI a lot you don’t recognize it. Shocker…
I can only quote another poster who told you:
again, you might be right, but your arguments are poor.
Perhaps you get this every single time because a statement of “this is AI” followed by “trust me bro” isn’t as convincing an argument as you seem to think it is ?
I don’t dispute your ability to detect LLM generated text in larger samples, but this sample is way too short and too “natural” to be sure enough for such an accusation. How about you ask them directly whether they generated this text or not, and take their word for it? Because what’s the point of accusing them of using an LLM when it’s 1) impossible to prove and 2) irrelevant for the world at large?
Fuck you for giving a monopoly on a writing style to AI. AI copied good writers and those people still exist.
Good writers use more than just these few tricks where AI seems to struggle to not use them everywhere. Do you remember what posts like this would look like from some random etsy member pre-AI? Were they all expert writers using the same punchy voice?
Again… the unbelievable irony of being flamed for calling a post AI made on the fuck-AI community…
When you have no evidence other than “it uses effective writing techniques” of course you’re going to get flamed. You sound like a conspiracy theorist who thinks they can see something no one else can and it makes you special. Whereas all you’re really doing is distracting from the message of the post and trying to police everyone’s writing style.
Do you remember what posts like this would look like from some random etsy member pre-AI? Were they all expert writers using the same punchy voice?
Like youtube face/thumbnails? or listicles? or you know, the whole idea of clickbait.
Convergence to the most effective format of a media type is an established phenomena, especially in areas where there is some incentive.
again, you might be right, but your arguments are poor.
Perhaps you get this every single time because a statement of “this is AI” followed by “trust me bro” isn’t as convincing an argument as you seem to think it is ?
I used to have a ton of soap etsy listings and a large soap Instagram. I am super wordy.
I had competitors cropping up making repeated listings after ai was popularized using my tone and cadence in their listings. I used to be teased in the soap community cause I wouldn’t shut up because id get so excited about every little detail id include in each soap. LLM I guess thought it was great so now that’s what listings look like for so many other people. I had a tag line I would end all my posts with, stay sudsy, and people were even generating descriptions and including that too. I know I don’t own that phrase, but every post for 7 years ended in stay sudsy and I guess it got scraped from Instagram.
I had built a business and community over years and it was just snatched from me. And the best part was many of those ‘soapers’ found more success than I could because they churned out more bulk basic soap, but had the same character of my small boutique business.
It sucks.
LLMs overweight the style of this particular context of short explanatory posts (not quite long enough for a full blog post but generally longer than a Facebook status or a tweet) for public consumption. LinkedIn is where a lot of this type of post lives, and LLMs tend to borrow from those conventions and extend them outside of that context.
But that stuff started there for a reason — em dash clauses are an efficient method to give a broad statement and then elaborate/explain in detail after, or by giving an example after.
- Bullet points are an easy way to visually organize things into lists
- Bullet points also are easy to textually encode in markdown, which is a friendly format for both training data and LLM output, because of the way LLMs work
It’s not just that the “it’s not X, it’s Y” sentence structure comes from LLMs; rather, it becomes some kind of logical negative space, that complements the other type of em dash explainer — the general then specific elaboration.
Many of us learned to write in specific mechanical styles for corporate communications. Those rules aren’t that complex, so it stands to reason that those rules end up getting incorporated into how machines generate text, too. But most of us have been doing it for a while, and oscillate between avoiding sounding like LLMs and defiantly using those conventions and saying stuff like why should I change, he’s the one who sucks.
No, I didn’t quit using em dashes, bullets, or “it’s not X” sentences. But I do use them more judiciously. And because of that, I recognize when they are still absolutely worth the overhead of people accusing the text of being LLM-written.
Dude it’s a large language model, of course there will be intersections with normal speech patterns or people may speak that way themselves. Especially as the output of LLMs becomes more and more commonplace and intersects with our normal vernacular and cadence.
Isn’t that just the nature of the beast?
I get this every single time… there are specific tells for LLMs and y’all are blind to them I swear…
I would agree with you if it wasn’t structured like unedited vanilla LLM output that people meme about
It’s not X, it’s Y.
There’s also the plain as day pandemic of content creators defaulting to AI to write viral punchy posts because it can do it so quickly. Youtube is 80% AI generated at this point as well it seems… nobody writes their own scripts anymore.
burden of proof is on the accuser.
Not to say you have to justify your every comment, but people asking for justification is to be expected.
a “trust me bro” doesn’t usually carry that much weight.
the LLM equivalent of :

You don’t have to believe me. I think my strongest points are the study I linked and this community’s inability to tell when I argue with them using LLMs. If anywhere on Lemmy is going to have AI content slip past detection it’s the community where people say fuck AI and try not to use it.
I was simply stating your strongest points were unconvincing in general type.
In this specific context, still unconvincing , but that doesn’t imply correctness, just lack of persuasive efficacy.
@homesweethomeMrL@lemmy.world idk if this is your business but you should check out or recommend artisans.coop/
Etsy was no more when they went hard into ‘Alligator Alcatraz’ and refused to do anything about it.
earlier… when they started allowing all the temu and aliexpress imported shit and abandoned the handmade or vintage theme that the site was built upon.











