Copyright law is to blame for the book thing. I’ve been explaining this since before they started. When you demand they stop grabbing torrents… the only legal way to have a backup copy of a text is to scan your physical edition. Even if the author’s been dead for most of a century and the publisher went under shortly after. And then you can never resell it, because it stops being a backup, and counts exactly the same as piracy.
The alternative for most of those private scans is that the books would be in the garbage without anyone scanning them.
You should want copyright relaxed to where these companies can throw a PDF on Archive.org and brag about preservation.
He should die. I’m a musician and fuck him for stealing our works.
‘I don’t like how my voice sounds, so I used a synth.’
‘Murder! Murder him immediately! I am the reasonable party!’
Well, a synth is not created on the fucking literal theft of other people’s work.
Not literal. Piracy is not theft, and this is less than that. Using some tiny part of many prior works, to make new art, is how art has always worked.
Adapting a comp sci joke, one blues-rock guitarist tells another “I took your song,” and they reply “It’s not my song.”
Ehhh… No.
Humans do understand, machines no.
Even worse, AI is doing mostly literal verbatim copypaste, as I, and other friends of mine, have experienced directly.
Also, I don’t know you, but I’m not pirating things from indie people, or mid-sized groups. If you’re doing that, you’re a dick.
But they’re doing that, and even worse, they’re enclosing it. They’re literally even fucking destroying books.
Copyright law is to blame for the book thing. I’ve been explaining this since before they started. When you demand they stop grabbing torrents… the only legal way to have a backup copy of a text is to scan your physical edition. Even if the author’s been dead for most of a century and the publisher went under shortly after. And then you can never resell it, because it stops being a backup, and counts exactly the same as piracy.
The alternative for most of those private scans is that the books would be in the garbage without anyone scanning them.
You should want copyright relaxed to where these companies can throw a PDF on Archive.org and brag about preservation.