The usual lib thing of “Imagine a hypothetical where every bit of relevant information was different than reality. Your position doesn’t look so good in that hypothetical now, does it?”
no no, it’s simple. imagine you’re a grain of rice, and you fall out of the kettle before being boiled. now imagine the rest of the rice is israel, doesnt sound so realistic now?? ha didnt think so
I think she’s accusing leftists of being reflexively anti American and hypocritical of oppression that comes from non NATO countries. Or maybe she’s saying leftists are antisemitic because “if Stalin was Jewish they’d call it genocide.” But it’s still incomprehensible word soup.
What is she trying to say? Genuinely.
The usual lib thing of “Imagine a hypothetical where every bit of relevant information was different than reality. Your position doesn’t look so good in that hypothetical now, does it?”
It’s kind of wild how much of neoliberal ideology relies on hypotheticals.
Just pure idealism
Stalin supported the idea of a Jewish state, which makes him the same as Killary Killton
Which if she were Israeli, means that the Ukrainian famine of the 30’s was intentional on behalf of Israeli Hillary Stalin
Therefore checkmate commies!
It is like freeform jazz with words. The point is the feeling it created. This is pure shallow liberalism distilled
Sure, but consider for a moment:
Jazz is sick and cool, while this tweet fucking sucks shit
It’s all about the points she didn’t make dude
no no, it’s simple. imagine you’re a grain of rice, and you fall out of the kettle before being boiled. now imagine the rest of the rice is israel, doesnt sound so realistic now??
ha didnt think so
I think she’s accusing leftists of being reflexively anti American and hypocritical of oppression that comes from non NATO countries. Or maybe she’s saying leftists are antisemitic because “if Stalin was Jewish they’d call it genocide.” But it’s still incomprehensible word soup.
Reposting my comment:
Imagine Stalin was replaced by a neoliberal politician with a proven track record of doing evil shit. Imagine the USSR was instead a settler-colonial genocide state. Imagine this state still takes up the geographical and historical spot the USSR does, somehow. Imagine everything else is the same, somehow. Now with these hypotheticals, would the holodomor not appear as a deliberate act of genocide? (By the way, the causes for the famine that wasn’t just located to Ukraine, but we pretend it is for some reason, are still the same. That means the holodomor was still a result of landowning farmers burning their stock of food rather than let it be redistributed.)