I thought it was a cannon and the rhyme retold a historical event: the king spent his money on an army of soldiers and horses instead of infrastructure (fixing the wall). All those horses and men cannot make up for the loss of the wall and cannon.
Iirc, the egg thing was not a solid part of the “meme” of humpty until Lewis Carroll. I might be crossing things up. But, depending on the origin one wants to pick from, our big dumpty friend from nursery rhymes could either be an egg, hump-backed king, a cannon, or just a clumsy person. Well, in terms of inspiration anyway; because of how history has turned it into an egg, and the lack of definitive record of origin, it’s all a glorious mess lol.
Yeah, I don’t know where this notion that he was an egg. I think it was Shrek or some similar thing that brought it to my attention that everyone thought he was supposed to be an egg.
I always thought he was just a dumb dude. Just pictured him court jester for most of my youth.
Humpty Dumpty was the name of a big cannon in the English civil war. It fell off a wall and broke. The other side made up the ryhme about it as a joke.
Me, slowly becoming Humpty-Dumpty-pilled
I think I read somewhere that Humpty-Dumpty was a cannon?
And your mother was a hamster and your father smelt of elderberries!
~Sorry, it felt strangely appropriate for some reason.~
I’ll accept your apology if you bring me…
A shrubbery!
Best I can do are coconuts. 🥥 🥥
Roger, is that you?
I thought it was a cannon and the rhyme retold a historical event: the king spent his money on an army of soldiers and horses instead of infrastructure (fixing the wall). All those horses and men cannot make up for the loss of the wall and cannon.
Is it a reference to the muddy origins and possible meaning of the riddle/nursery rhyme?
Humpty-Dumpty is never explicitly described as an egg in the nursery rhyme.
Thought it had to be something along those lines.
Iirc, the egg thing was not a solid part of the “meme” of humpty until Lewis Carroll. I might be crossing things up. But, depending on the origin one wants to pick from, our big dumpty friend from nursery rhymes could either be an egg, hump-backed king, a cannon, or just a clumsy person. Well, in terms of inspiration anyway; because of how history has turned it into an egg, and the lack of definitive record of origin, it’s all a glorious mess lol.
I don’t get it. How was humpty done poorly?
Where is it ever stated that hems an egg?
i usually hem with a needle
I’m not fit to touch the hem of your garment
Yes, but are you intrinsically no good?
Yeah, I don’t know where this notion that he was an egg. I think it was Shrek or some similar thing that brought it to my attention that everyone thought he was supposed to be an egg.
I always thought he was just a dumb dude. Just pictured him court jester for most of my youth.
Lewis Caroll in the 1800s
TIL Shrek was first written in the 1800s. I’m glad they finally made the movie version!
Nah, was way before Shrek. I remember back in early 90s in elementary school seeing Humpty as an egg.
Care to share?
Humpty Dumpty was the name of a big cannon in the English civil war. It fell off a wall and broke. The other side made up the ryhme about it as a joke.
Some say the cannon origin is misattributed as well, just another layer cough, another egg reference to this joke
Today I learned.
Thank you.
Humpty-Dumpty is never explicitly described as an egg in the nursery rhyme.