A 2-year-old girl has died after her father left her in a hot car in Arizona, where residents are enduring triple-digit temperatures, according to authorities.
The father was running errands with his daughter, and when he returned home Tuesday afternoon, he allegedly knowingly left the 2-year-old in the car, Marana Police Capt. Tim Brunenkant told ABC News.
He left the car running and the air conditioning on, Brunenkant said.
The dad went into the house, and when he returned to the car between 30 and 60 minutes later, the car was off, Brunenkant said.
The dad went into the house, and when he returned to the car between 30 and 60 minutes later
This is the part that really confuses me, they were home. I get that parents sometimes need a break from their kid but:
- You’re home, so take your kid inside and then you go somewhere else.
- 30 to 60 minutes?!? I can understand taking 10 minutes (which is still a dangerous amount of time) but WTF was going on for 30 to 60 minutes.
I know it’s not the point of the article, but I’m also annoyed at the idea of someone intending to run their car for 30-60 minutes for no reason. I will admit I’ve left my car running just for the comfort of A/C while I’m waiting, and I don’t live in Arizona heat, but dude was home.
I’ll leave this article here but fair warning, it’s a tough read
That’s very different though. This article states he “knowingly left the 2-year-old in the car”.
Wow I was really tired and missed that keyword, damn that’s messed up. Definitely liable
deleted by creator
They know. It’s a different article and also a different situation. The article doesn’t apply
deleted by creator
The only thing aside from wanting a break was maybe the kid was asleep and the engine keeps them asleep? Cars put lots of kids to sleep.
Didn’t want to wake the kid and wanted the break?
Not an excuse though, should have stayed in the car if that’s what was up.
That’s Standard dad-poop session.he must’ve really been turtling. But if it came down to it, i would poop my pants and let my kid live. But i’m a good dad.
Try that fucker for murder.
Yeah this isn’t a tragic accident, like they so often are.
This is straight neglect.
It doesn’t say, but as a parent of five kids, I’m going to bet the 2 year old fell asleep and dad didn’t want to wake her. Maybe I’m being too generous, but I guess I’d need more information to be so certain about judging them.
I’ve probably done shit like this before although I’d never let the car out of my sight. And certainly not in 111 degrees. A/C doesn’t really work that well when the car isn’t in motion.
As a parent of 4 kids I can safely say I would never leave them in a car in that heat. No matter the circumstances.
Agreed. You can carry a 2y inside or stay with them in the car to make sure they’re safe
What I imagine has led decent parents to tragedy:
-
Change in Routine - daily schedule changes after years of it being the exact same, now suddenly your coparent is sick or something and you get the kid
-
Sleeping Child
-
Miscommunication - parents believe the other already took the child out
Can you imagine… man. Most mistakes, consequences are more like you have to drive back to the store to pickup the milk you forgot. Not a lifetime of regret and maybe jail time, lawyers’ fees, judgement…
-
Why was the car off when he returned if he left it running with the AC on?
It’s a tragedy, but if I’m on the jury I’m not sure I would convict him.
Many modern vehicles automatically turn off after 30-60 minutes idling “to save fuel”. I order to turn it off you have to hit the A button on the dash. it’s proven to be deadly.
Just curious, what kind of deadly situation is created when people leave their cars idling for so long?
I’m the kind of person that turns the car off if there is a train coming and I need to wait 5 minutes. I can’t imagine leaving the car running for more than a couple of minutes.
I think if the car is turned on with a button and the key is replaced with a card that works at a distance, a feature that turns the car off when sitting idle for a while seems like a sensible thing. It’s way more likely to be on by mistake than left running for a reason.
But would love to hear what kind of situations there are, I’m just unfamiliar with them.
First obviously you don’t want to let a car idle in an enclosed space. That’s deadly to anyone in the car/garage but also potentially to folks inside the house if it is poorly ventilated.
I would definitely want the car running in 111 degree heat, even when stopped for a train or in a fast food line.
On the other hand, my vehicle, a Chevy Volt PHEV will turn itself off after about 4 hours. While this seems logical, a lot of people who camp inside it or use it to power their camp gear find it really inconvenient to have everything turn off at 1AM. So they recommend a hair tie around the gear shift button to keep the car from turning off.
So there are reasons both for having an auto-off feature and for not having it.
Leaving a two-year-old alone in a car for 30-60 minutes (he doesn’t even know how long he was gone)
isn’tis criminal in and of itself regardless of the weather. On top of that, he knew it was in the triple digits and he’s also not so stupid that he doesn’t know that cars can break down. I don’t know what to tell you. I just hope you aren’t responsible for any toddlers.Edit: Stupid typo.
Leaving a two-year-old alone in a car for 30-60 minutes (he doesn’t even know how long he was gone) isn’t criminal in and of itself regardless of the weather.
… ummmm, yes it is. Leaving a toddler unattended for an extended period of time is literally multiple crimes.
Oops. Meant is criminal.
deleted by creator
I suppose it’s possible if the cooling system isn’t functioning correctly, but as far as I know, properly functioning, it should be able to idle in triple digits just fine.
Yes.
Dad also should have been able to knowingly remove child from car instead of knowingly leave child in car.
deleted by creator
Any number of things can go wrong in any number of situations, but you can’t effectively live life accounting for all of them to possibly happen all the time.
Not saying it was the best decision but I don’t think it’s unreasonable to think the car would keep the AC on.
It’s definitely a tragedy. The article is too light on information to convict was all I was saying.
They knowingly left their 2 year old alone for 30-60 minutes. That’s already illegal.
A lot of things are illegal that aren’t murder.
Wow, so it would be illegal for parents to sleep? Gtfo
My mom’s car, a mid-'10s Acura, will turn itself off if you leave with the key and get too far away from the car for too long without enabling valet mode.
Most modern cars have an auto-off feature. Some have a button to temporarily disable it.
Mine is one such car but it only turns itself off while in drive to save gas at stoplights and such. It doesn’t turn itself off when running while in park.
You’re thinking of the auto start-stop feature. That is a different feature which aims to save gas while you press the brake pedal.
What others in the thread are talking about is a feature that will fully power off the vehicle after it has been sitting idle for a longer period of time. This includes turning off the engine and any of the electronics that normally continue to run during the auto start-stop.
Could be but it must have a very long timeout. My wife frequently opts to wait in the car while I go run an errand, but I’ve admittedly never timed it. 30min would definitely be on the high end though. If I ever made her wait 60 I’d probably be divorced.
My 2020 VW Golf definitely turns itself off when in park, but also has the button to disable it.
It will even require a manual restart if it’s been parked long enough, which gets annoying when I spend a little too long dropping off/picking up something, and don’t notice the message, put it in drive, see the message and try to start the car, but can’t until I put it back in park. /rant
I do hate that you can’t permanently disable the feature. Disabling it has (mostly) become a standard part of my startup procedure, but every once in a while I get in a hurry and forget. It makes me unreasonably irritated when I do and the car turns off at an intersection even though all I have to do is slightly lift my foot on the brake not even enough to release the brake. Then I get irritated at myself for forgetting and again for getting irritated so easily.
My car tracks how much idle time it has saved and after 3 years I’m still at something like 10 seconds…
IMHO, you shouldn’t be able to permanently disable it. We are in a climate crisis.
It’s fine for 95% of use cases, but sucks for the rest. But having anyone restrict my ability to make choices for what is best for me and my situation puts a black mark on my book.
Because it looks like it may have been a tesla and those are failure machines for idiots.
The car probably had “AI” face detection of vulnerable children in high heat conditions which then triggered a “surge subscription” notification on the app. “Upgrade to infant climate+ NOW, in the next 2 minutes, or your air conditioning will be temporarily shifted to heater until you decide to upgrade. Thank you.”
This reminds me of that post about how to spot a kid on the Internet. Insane extreme takes and an inability to understand nuance.
10 years ago no car would automatically turn off if you left it running. It would only stop if it ran out of gas (which could be days). You want to charge a man with murder because he didn’t memorize the owner’s manual.
You want to charge a man with murder because he didn’t memorize the owner’s manual
They were at home. Father got home at 2:45 mother got home at 4:00 and 911 call at 4:10. The father left this poor child in the car for over an hour. You want to blame the fucking car?!
This shit is so fucking infuriating. That innocent child suffered before she died.
I blast my AC full blast and roll down all the windows just to pump gas in heat.
You shouldn’t have the car running while pumping gas.
Did I mention I light up a cigarette, pull out my phone, then almost at the end I hold a water bottle and try to see if I can shoot… I turn my car off.
This is sort of a southerner thing. Up north, many gas stations actually ask you to keep your engine running while you pump. Because when it’s -20 degrees outside, turning your engine off is just asking to get stranded. And if you get stranded at a gas station overnight, (like when the lobby has closed but the pumps are still active for card transactions,) there’s a good chance you’ll be dead in the parking lot by the time the morning crew shows up to open.
Apparently southerners think “up north” is identical to Nome, Alaska 365 days a year.
Nah, my family’s just from Wisconsin.
I have never seen this in new England. Where is that common?
Do you mean diesel? Literally never heard of this for regular cars
As a fellow parent, I will never empathize or sympathize with these poor decisions. How could you leave your fucking child in the car, NO MATTER THE CIRCUMSTANCES. Idgaf if they were sleeping or whatever. Idgaf how exhausted you are. You have a responsibility to your child. If they are so difficult to keep put them up for adoption or some shit. I’ve never and could never forget my kids or leave my kids somewhere like this. This is pure stupidity.
I don’t think he should be charged but the mother should be entitled to a divorce with alimony at the expense of the father. He is the type of person to not give a shit about anyone but himself.
I really want to wonder why this keeps happening but some people are just careless or evil. Or both.
They’re stupid and trust the car to keep running.
Looks like that’s a tesla roped off there, because of course that’s the type of person that would have this level of thought and irresponsibility. Person was probably watching YouTube videos about babies being too woke and not enough high temperature exposure being the coddling culprit. Or “natural vaccines with heat exposure therapy!”
The only appropriate sentence for these types of crimes is for the “parent” to be sealed in a glass box for all to witness, in the center of town, without water, in the Phoenix sun, until they experience the same avoidable fate.
Child protective services need to remove any other children from these homes.
I really hate motherfuckers that idle their car
