
I enjoy Northernlion’s videos not because of the gameplay, but because of the commentary around it.
I’m pretty sure the algorithm rewards videos shorter than 10 min. Isn’t that why they invented shorts?
On the contrary, when a video commits to being so unbelievably long and edited as it should be (a rabbit hole/spiral) it can become some of the most memorable stuff you can find on YT.
HE WASN’T EVEN ON CRIBS
This is just one of those things that separates us from 4chan I guess
One of my favorite videos is SovietWomble’s 3 hour essay on The Forest. It’s full of tangents and touches on like every survival game ever, but it comes together so beautifully at the end to show you how important proper planning is when tackling such a big project.
Huh? Just watched two 3hrs+ videos on NieR:Automata and NieR:Replicant (I’ve played both, and back then also watched YouTube empty of NieR content. These have been uploaded since). Next in queue is a 6hrs video on the full history of the NieR universe.
The only thing I loathe with a passion in long video essays is when they promise analysis or interpretation, but then it’s just the most basic-ass recap, stretched out for 2hrs. Gimme your opinions and thoughts, man (or woman or emby)!
Jesus Christ how do y’all have time for even one 3+ hr video? Are you 12?
I love videoessays, though.
In Spanish there’s this youtuber, BaityBait, that analyzes them through a psychological, legal, philosophical, cultural and economical angle (he’s so polyfacetic!), with some spicy and sometimes acid (also sometimes just absurd) humor in it. It’s so peak.
Thanks! Watching his video about falling out of love with video games right now.
;3
That one is FAYAAAAAAAA
I just don’t watch long videos, with the exception of Jenny Nicholson’s rant about that Disney hotel. If it takes longer than an episode of an actual show I’ll just watch that.
Angela Collier’s takedown of Star Trek: Picard is also world class long form entertainment.
This is so true, the only long videos I watch are like:
- History
- Philosophy
- maybe film analysis
Even then there’s so many crapshot wastes of time to cut out. I sucked my own dick this morning. I’ve whittled the list down to like, “HealthyGamersGG” (Dr Olek K) and one guy called Academic Agent who is almost always fun. He does philosophy.
Jacob Geller does a reliably good job with his longer gaming videos if you haven’t seen any of them, might be worth checking out
I get sick of this with blender tutorials too. Like I’m just trying to find the name of a specific node, or how to do a very specific thing. Videos are all like 30 minutes when the actual content named in the title is at most 60 seconds of words.
I don’t need your 2 minute into with music and a swirly graphic then give minutes of you introducing yourself, and basic ui controls at the start of every single video. Just say the thing and fuck off.
It’s YouTube’s fault with the way they monetize videos. Ruining their own damn platform. Same as Reddit.
It used to be you could find what you were looking for in a blog post with clear instructions. It pisses me off to no end when the information I’m looking for is buried in a shit video because everyone is illiterate now.
It’s been that way for at least a decade maybe longer. I hate video tutorials for most things, when I can read it in a minute why watch 30 min?
Exactly.
Not everyone is illiterate, but all literacy is useless slop now
The problem here is short attention span and tiktok brain rot. I really enjoy long gaming retrospectives.
Long videos have their place. If it’s a video about how to change the RAM in a laptop, it shouldn’t be 30 minutes long giving me 3 minutes of TV Dinner delivery ad, 2 more interruptions for VPNs and Dark Web monitoring ads followed by all the reasons for why changing the RAM in my laptop is a good idea and the history of where the ram used to be in older models. Just show me where the clips and screws are so I don’t break my fucking laptop when I change out the RAM.
The problem is the YouTube algorithm pushes longer videos at the moment, because longer videos tend to keep people on the platform. So, creators trying to game that system are filling time with useless bullshit.
I don’t use tiktok or any of its competitors. I also enjoy the longer videos, when they’re well done. So many of them are clearly just filling space that I can’t really trust the recommended video feed anymore. I turned something on from a creator I didn’t recognize the other day, watched a few minutes to let him get to the point, slipped ahead to the first 3rd, which tends to be the spot the get to the point at, still bullshit, skipped ahead to the halfway point, same bullshit, skipped to the last third where finally he was making the case for his title.
This video was 30 minutes long. He had roughly 4 minutes of content that wasn’t just bullshit. That happens with just about every video from a creator I don’t recognize now. There was quite a bit of effort to produce the video that long, it wasn’t just random slop thrown up there, there were relevant graphics for the entire thing. He just didn’t have shit to say. But needed a long video.
deleted by creator
"… And that’s why today, I’m going to go over everything I love about this new game!
(Channel logo)
Video games were invented in 1958 with the creation of Tennis for Two…"
I mean I’m a history and video game nerd and would love a video with the latter premise.
Until you’ve heard it a million times because they all read the same Wikipedia page to fill time.
My favorite is when they collectively get a detail wrong because somebody said it wrong first and nobody looked in to it before repeating it, somebody comes up with more accurate video and gets absolutely trashed for it.
I don’t mid long videos (I finished joshimuz’s 20h+ San Andreas randomizer video and many other long 5h+ videos) if it entertaining
I love me a good long-form video - I’ve sat through 4+ hour long ones about various topics and found it quite enjoyable time spent, but for every good one, there’s a hundred that’re exactly as this describes. It’s the Youtube equivalent of “This meeting could have been an email”… “This essay could have been a short.”
“It’s the Youtube equivalent of ‘This meeting could have been an email’”
Exactly! I hate long videos with a passion. And the useless banter
Yeah someone shared a video not too long ago about 2000s beach aesthetics (edit: in videogames). It was like 30 minutes long so I was expecting them to get to the interesting nitty gritty of art direction. But nope, it was like 25 minutes how the creator feels when he sees the old games. And the “reason” was mentioned in the last 5 minutes but it was so uninteresting I don’t remember. It didn’t have any sponsors so I just wrote it off as, “I’m not their target audience.”
Any Austin is great at this. The videos could be shorter yes, but it’s relaxing to watch.
I feel many creators don’t prepare their text, but just start talking until they feel they’ve said all they can think of. It’s really noticeable, in a good way, if someone actually prepares their video.
Having said that, there are also writers who really could use an editor. Cory Doctorow and Edward Zitron have a lot of interesting things to say, but they use way too many words to do so.
Zitron, sure, but Doctorow? Too much filler?
I don’t want to say they write filler, because it’s usually all relevant to the point they’re making, but their blogs are so long I just can’t get through.
I go one step further and ask: why a video at all? I’ll take text over a video any day, when it’s just some rando talking about stuff.
hmm i’d say that sometimes it’s nice to hear someone talk. depends on the topic, but it can make good mood. reading long texts alone in a dark room can be monotonic.
Flat affected inner monologue isn’t a thing everybody has. It’s not common, from what I’m able to gather. Might be spectrum related.
because you can’t do anything else while reading
But you can just scan until you get to the part that’s relevant for you and be done in 30 seconds while only having to focus on one thing at a time. With the video when I start doing other things I’ll lose track and realize I missed something and have to go back.
I can listen to music while reading.
I actually really like to read something light (like gaming news) while listening to music, otherwise I often fall asleep. (Work, family, you know how it is.)
I’ll also fall asleep while watching a talking head, so my options are limited :P It just doesn’t keep my brain engaged.
That’s a reasonable argument for audio, but not for video, isn’t it?













