The transition point is not the number of properties just like it isn’t the dollar amount of income. The transition point is whether or not, in the method they are using, they need to contribute their own labor beyond perfunctory business decisions and things of that nature. If someone has one unit, but due to inflated rental prices it can be fully maintained and mostly managed by employees, then the owner is bourgeois. Realistically, you need more units than that, but it’s not about a pre-defined number of units (which by the way isn’t accounting for variance among units). It varies place to place based on rent inflation, labor laws, housing regulation, taxation, etc.
Rent-seeking is just kind of a different form of bourgeois than bosses. They converge at higher scales, but when they’re small enough that they operate on distinct terms, I think you can call them both petty. But it’s tough to say exactly. For boss-type bougies, it’s super straightforward - if their labor is still required for the operation to run, they’re petty. Not so clear with landlords. Maybe if it reaches a threshold where they no longer need a separate laboring job?
I feel like multi-property airbnb hosts aren’t even petite-bourgeois since their just landlords. I feel like their just big bourgeoisie
Imo unless they have a huge operation where an entire staff of employees is running everything for them, they’re still petit bourg.
Even owning just a few houses is enough to pay for a staff to clean them and even manage the airbnb page?
but that would mean lower profits? did you consider that?
Yeah but a few houses is still relatively precarious to the big bourg. I’m thinking the transition point is maybe a dozen or so properties.
The transition point is not the number of properties just like it isn’t the dollar amount of income. The transition point is whether or not, in the method they are using, they need to contribute their own labor beyond perfunctory business decisions and things of that nature. If someone has one unit, but due to inflated rental prices it can be fully maintained and mostly managed by employees, then the owner is bourgeois. Realistically, you need more units than that, but it’s not about a pre-defined number of units (which by the way isn’t accounting for variance among units). It varies place to place based on rent inflation, labor laws, housing regulation, taxation, etc.
Agreed entirely, just saying that my gut feeling is that one would need 10+ properties to hit that point.
Many likely do not own the houses outright. The bank owns it, and they are using the business to pay off the mortgage.
So it’s the poor landlords who are the real victims here 🥺. Damn those big nasty banks!
Rent-seeking is just kind of a different form of bourgeois than bosses. They converge at higher scales, but when they’re small enough that they operate on distinct terms, I think you can call them both petty. But it’s tough to say exactly. For boss-type bougies, it’s super straightforward - if their labor is still required for the operation to run, they’re petty. Not so clear with landlords. Maybe if it reaches a threshold where they no longer need a separate laboring job?