cross-posted from: https://scribe.disroot.org/post/12537294
…
A former national security adviser to the prime minister says she would not personally buy a Chinese electric vehicle.
“I think that anybody who does buy a Chinese EV needs to understand it is a computer on wheels, and all of their information about what they do and where they’re going is going back to the Chinese government,” Jody Thomas said during a panel interview with other China experts on CTV Power Play with Vassy Kapelos on Tuesday, when asked whether she has any concerns from a security perspective about the technology.
…
The former national security adviser — who was NSIA to former prime minister Justin Trudeau from 2022 to 2024 — made the comments as the prospect of manufacturing Chinese EVs in Canada is examined by the federal government. Premier Doug Ford has urged the Carney government to exercise caution about any Chinese involvement in the auto sector.
…
[Canada PM Mark] Carney also said Canada could turn to Chinese automakers if trade talks with the U.S. fail.
There was no new announcement, however, on Chinese EVs entering Canada, with the two countries maintaining the agreement reached in January 2026. At the time, Carney announced a deal that would see Canada reduce its tariff rate from 100 per cent to 6.1 per cent on Chinese EVs and allow up to 49,000 Chinese-made electric vehicles into the Canadian market.
…
Speaking on the panel, Thomas said there is “absolutely no doubt,” that Chinese EVs are “a security concern.”
…
“It is a very small deal [between Canada and China] in terms of EVs, but the potential to grow is there, and I think there is significant concern both for the auto industry here, but also for the proliferation of those kinds of vehicles,” she added.
…
There is nothing Chinese cars are doing, that Canadian or American made cars are not. Maybe the problem isn’t who is spying on you, maybe the problem is that anyone is allowed to spy on you.
Tesla is far worse.
Elon is watching you pick your nose. Also listening for you to talk about proprietary IP
Would never be in one of those Swasticars.
If anything, buying a computer on wheels from a country on the opposite side of the world rather than your native home country is probably better for you. If that foreign country becomes a fascist reigeme they are unlikely to care about you and your driving habits. If your native country becomes a fascist reigeme, thats a very different story.
Also if you are currently or were a national security advisor, of course you would not purchase foreign technology which can easily be controlled by a foreign entity to influence you or listen in to your conversations.
I feel as though such remarks are pointless.
I’m not sure why I’m supposed to be more concerned about China knowing the layout of my house or how often I go to the store than the American government or private companies. Of them all, China is the furthest away and least important in my life.
Maybe if I were a government official or Chinese dissident it would be of some consideration, but I’m of no interest to the Chinese government.
Still better than a Tesla.
I have read it more as a matter of national and personal security. In this period of hybrid wars and software systems breaking down unexpectedly, you probably don’t want to give a foreign government the ability to remotely shut down your car, your internet or your heating (especially a government that has an up-and-down relationship with yours).
Buying either instead of European or Japanese is generally stupid. And even then, why buy an overpriced BMW when you can buy a Toyota which won’t cost more than most Americans spend on healthcare for a decade.
From the Hilux in the middle east to the camry in the middle east (of Ohio), convenience, repairability, and low tech remains supreme.
My man hasn’t checked Toyota prices in a while.
Buying either instead of European or Japanese is generally stupid.
Thank you for this sophisticated comment. /s
Genuinely the reason why I refuse to buy a modern ev.
I want my car to bring me from point a to point b. I do not want it to share my driving statistics to insurance companies, nor I don’t want my car recordings to be sent to the car company’s cloud servers. I do not want my car to refuse working because it needs a software update. I do not want touchscreen for all controls that will inevitably start ghosting over long time use. This issue was solved long ago; with fucking buttons.
Modern EVs are not worse than modern ICEs for this, and there are still options with buttons (Hyundia-Kia-Genesis, for example, and Toyota bZs).
Genuinely the reason I refuse to buy any modern car, EV or otherwise.
But I think saying “EV” instead of “car” is valid in that statement anyway, because wanting it to be electric is the thing that limits you to “modern” vehicles in the first place. If you reject telemetry but ICE cars are acceptable then there are still old ones to choose from, but not so much for EVs.
The engine does not make a difference, EV or gas powered is the same.
There’s Slate. In base configuration, it’s very stripped down. No cell radio, telemetry module, or entertainment computer. You get a mount for a tablet or phone and can bring your own.
Downside is that it has a relatively short range. After Trump killed the battery subsidies, it switched from more-expensive but available in North America NMC to less-energy-dense (but cheaper) LFP, which also shaved some range off the maximum.
Outside of that, some vehicles let you disable their telemetry modules. I was looking this up, and on at least some recent Toyotas, for example, you can open up the car and disconnect the power that goes to the telemetry module. That’ll kill both the GPS unit and the cell radio. Absent additional rewiring, you will lose one speaker, as it’s hooked up to emergency accident handling stuff, which is tied to the telemetry module. You also obviously lose functionality related to GPS, and your car comouter will display a warning that it can’t communicate with the telemetry module. I did ask a local Toyota auto shop, and they said that they’d happily disconnect the module if a customer wanted, so you don’t have to be a gearhead to get done, but it’ll have those drawbacks. I don’t know whether doing so is viable on all makes, models, and years of auto, but if you want, you could research that for a given car.
The real downside of Slate is that it doesn’t actually exist yet.
Sure, it should be available Soon™, but until you can actually buy and take delivery of it, it doesn’t count.





