cross-posted from: https://scribe.disroot.org/post/12537294
…
A former national security adviser to the prime minister says she would not personally buy a Chinese electric vehicle.
“I think that anybody who does buy a Chinese EV needs to understand it is a computer on wheels, and all of their information about what they do and where they’re going is going back to the Chinese government,” Jody Thomas said during a panel interview with other China experts on CTV Power Play with Vassy Kapelos on Tuesday, when asked whether she has any concerns from a security perspective about the technology.
…
The former national security adviser — who was NSIA to former prime minister Justin Trudeau from 2022 to 2024 — made the comments as the prospect of manufacturing Chinese EVs in Canada is examined by the federal government. Premier Doug Ford has urged the Carney government to exercise caution about any Chinese involvement in the auto sector.
…
[Canada PM Mark] Carney also said Canada could turn to Chinese automakers if trade talks with the U.S. fail.
There was no new announcement, however, on Chinese EVs entering Canada, with the two countries maintaining the agreement reached in January 2026. At the time, Carney announced a deal that would see Canada reduce its tariff rate from 100 per cent to 6.1 per cent on Chinese EVs and allow up to 49,000 Chinese-made electric vehicles into the Canadian market.
…
Speaking on the panel, Thomas said there is “absolutely no doubt,” that Chinese EVs are “a security concern.”
…
“It is a very small deal [between Canada and China] in terms of EVs, but the potential to grow is there, and I think there is significant concern both for the auto industry here, but also for the proliferation of those kinds of vehicles,” she added.
…
significant concern both for the auto industry here
Canada is 15th in the world for cars produced, with the majority of cars produced being: Ford (American), GM (American), Honda (Japanese), Stellantis (Dutch or American, depending on the tax year), and Toyota (Japanese.)
There are Canadian vehicle companies, none of which would compete with Chinese consumer EVs. Mainly because Canada isn’t an automotive producer country.
Like the solution would just be put in a BYD factory in Canada so it can be ‘Canadian’ by Canadian standards. Unfortunately because China is much, much better at automation than American companies, it’d only add like 200 jobs to outproduce all ‘domestic’ production, but it’d be as ‘Canadian’ as any other company then.
This is true of all new cars today and no one should buy any of them.
It’s funny for Thomas to point this out in regards EVs from China as indeed this is the case for nearly all new EVs (maybe excluding Slate) and nearly (probably) all ICE vehicles. Wired did an article on this over a year ago, so one would think that a “security advisor” would be aware of this issue. After all if two goofballs (you and me) on Fedi know this to be the case, why wouldn’t Thomas?
And most other EVs are different outside of where the data is sent? Spare me.




