crocotta [he/him]

  • 1 Post
  • 28 Comments
Joined 28 days ago
cake
Cake day: October 14th, 2026

help-circle




  • I think Why Socialism? works surprisingly well here as a sort of preface to the whole list, it’s at least tangential to most main topics. I was so ready to criticise its inclusion from the perspective of its target audience being completely different than the readers of this list, but I think it gives the list structure in a great way.

    While it is nice to have Uncle Ho on the list, I don’t think Why do we Have to Study Theory? quite does the thing a text about theory in the abstract should do here. I strongly believe there should be such a text here, but I can’t recommend one off the top of my head, sorry.

    I hadn’t read General Rules for Independent Study before, it’s pretty great. I would put it second on the list after Why Socialism? for practical reasons.

    Maybe “Tankies” would work better as the first thing in the section about imperialism? I think it feels a little repetitive here, with Why Marxism? making similar points, and the first two thirds of Lenin’s Imperialism are IMHO pretty dry and could use something like this to wash it down. There could be something short about social liberation here instead, but sadly I have no recommendation this time either.