The abilities of the Sardaukar were largely attributed to the harsh environment and brutal discipline they were exposed to on the planet Salusa Secundus, the Corrino prison planet. Only the Fremen, raised in the fanatical warrior culture and merciless desert environment of Arrakis, were capable of matching the Sardaukar. Fremen typically scorned Harkonnen soldiers as cowardly and weak, but judged that the Sardaukar fought well, and even respected them to some degree.
So what makes the greatest fighter in the narrative of the Dune universe is a merciless environment.
In the book, Baron Harkonnen unwittingly scares the emperor by suggesting making Dune a prison planet like Salusa Secundus. The emperor knows that is a way to make the best fighters - Baron Harkonnen did not.
The books is actually quite explicit about what makes the Fremen such good fighters - their hard environment shapes them.
Putting aside all the issues with that premise and accepting it as an axiom of Herbert’s world, you are quite right.
But precisely because it’s such an inintuitive notion that a force of desert-dwellers shaped by scarcity, lacking both the equipment and the training for shield combat and the rapid troop transport (that he knows of) to stage a surprise attack could suddenly attack and overcome his well-fed, -trained, -equipped professional army, I’d absolutely give him a pass on not expecting that too. What makes the Fremen so dangerous in the desert is that shields are useless and even dangerous out there, while they know the dangers and can use the terrain to their advantage. But in the city of Arrakeen?
The abilities of the Sardaukar were largely attributed to the harsh environment and brutal discipline they were exposed to on the planet Salusa Secundus, the Corrino prison planet.
Again, the Sardaukar also have dedicated training and equipment, which would give them a decisive edge over the unshielded Fremen.
The battle of Arrakeen, of course, happened without shields and generally on favourable terms for the Fremen, orchestrated by a prescient proto-mentat and generally fucking up the balance fiercely.
The books is actually quite explicit about what makes the Fremen such good fighters - their hard environment shapes them.
From https://dune.fandom.com/wiki/Sardaukar
So what makes the greatest fighter in the narrative of the Dune universe is a merciless environment.
In the book, Baron Harkonnen unwittingly scares the emperor by suggesting making Dune a prison planet like Salusa Secundus. The emperor knows that is a way to make the best fighters - Baron Harkonnen did not.
I think Paul being able to see the future was a major advantage.
Putting aside all the issues with that premise and accepting it as an axiom of Herbert’s world, you are quite right.
But precisely because it’s such an inintuitive notion that a force of desert-dwellers shaped by scarcity, lacking both the equipment and the training for shield combat and the rapid troop transport (that he knows of) to stage a surprise attack could suddenly attack and overcome his well-fed, -trained, -equipped professional army, I’d absolutely give him a pass on not expecting that too. What makes the Fremen so dangerous in the desert is that shields are useless and even dangerous out there, while they know the dangers and can use the terrain to their advantage. But in the city of Arrakeen?
Again, the Sardaukar also have dedicated training and equipment, which would give them a decisive edge over the unshielded Fremen.
The battle of Arrakeen, of course, happened without shields and generally on favourable terms for the Fremen, orchestrated by a prescient proto-mentat and generally fucking up the balance fiercely.