how can they even claim it’s e2ee if they also claim to log all the messages?
Who are the various "they"s in that question?
Signal claims that if you use the Signal app, it’s end-to-end encrypted. The Trump admin was using an unofficial Signal-compatible app TM SGNL which probably didn’t make those claims. And, Signal definitely never claimed that TM SGNL was end-to-end encrypted. In fact, it’s likely TeleMessage violated the copyrights and trademarks belonging to Signal with their app.
But, in the end, the messages were still technically end-to-end encrypted. It’s just that as soon as the messages arrived at one of those ends, they were sent to TeleMessage who archived them unencrypted in AWS. It’s still end-to-end encrypted, it’s just that one of those ends is incredibly leaky.
Who are the various "they"s in that question?
Signal claims that if you use the Signal app, it’s end-to-end encrypted. The Trump admin was using an unofficial Signal-compatible app TM SGNL which probably didn’t make those claims. And, Signal definitely never claimed that TM SGNL was end-to-end encrypted. In fact, it’s likely TeleMessage violated the copyrights and trademarks belonging to Signal with their app.
But, in the end, the messages were still technically end-to-end encrypted. It’s just that as soon as the messages arrived at one of those ends, they were sent to TeleMessage who archived them unencrypted in AWS. It’s still end-to-end encrypted, it’s just that one of those ends is incredibly leaky.