No-no, you misunderstand, William I was a baddie with a fat ass.
Ivan the Terrible was the grandson of Ivan the Great. His father, Vasili III, didn’t have an epithet, but everyone calls him the Average or something like that.
OOTL, what’s the deal with Kojima being considered bad writing?
Listen, we all need to breath through our skin, right?
I’m not OP, but I wouldn’t say his writing is bad, just that he is very on-the-nose with how he names people and things. Instead of giving the eccentric guy with a heart problem a name that subtly nods to his characterization, he goes for the unapologetically direct name of “Heartman”.
So in this case, instead of coming up with titles referencing a more indirect virtue or trait to represent the quality of each king, the chroniclers just settled on “bad” and “good” as epithets.
Honestly what he does with names is in fact a very strong writing technique. The audience only has so much bandwidth and will forget about 60% of what you tell them, but they retain names really well. So, you shouldn’t pick names that are meaningless. The names should highlight something you want the audience to retain, either by being on-the-nose (e.g. Remus Lupin, Treebeard, Darth Vader, Artemis Fowl, Heartman) or by being very ironic (e.g. Courage the Cowardly Dog, Flash Slothmore, Mr. Big, Nobby Nobbs, Little John).
but they retain names really well
Ha, you have obviously not met me yet: Forgets-names-in-5-seconds-man!
In all reality, that would pass as a Batman villain. Fits right in with Kite Man, Calendar Man, Condiment King, Polka Dot Man, The Mime, Ten-Eyed Man, Penny Plunderer, Moth, Bootface, Crazy Quilt, Eraser, Egghead, General, Zebra Man, White Rabbit, Professor Radium, Ragdoll, Pigeon Person, Mr. Freeze, Mr. Camera, Manbat…




