Skip Navigation
Fedigrow @lemmy.zip
jet @hackertalks.com

HiliariousChaos - Request for evidence

HilariousChaos.com is a instance started 2 years ago. 250 registered users, with 25 monthly active users.

team :

admin action modlog :

TOS which they post under their legal section

You may not transmit any Content that is unlawful, offensive, upsetting, intended to disgust, threatening, libelous, defamatory, obscene or otherwise objectionable. Examples of such objectionable Content include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • Unlawful or promoting unlawful activity.
  • Defamatory, discriminatory, or mean-spirited content, including references or commentary about religion, race, sexual orientation, gender, national/ethnic origin, or other targeted groups.
  • Spam, machine – or randomly – generated, constituting unauthorized or unsolicited advertising, chain letters, any other form of unauthorized solicitation, or any form of lottery or gambling. ....
  • Violating the privacy of any third person.

https://gui.fediseer.com/instances/detail/hilariouschaos.com

2 of the censures are n/a, 4 of the evidence sections are n/a, 1 censure is from a offline instance (dubvee).

Checked with lemmy-federate.com

@ada@lemmy.blahaj.zone (one of the censure issuers) points out they have a beef with one of the instance admins https://piefed.blahaj.zone/comment/895309

A single user behaving badly shouldn't be enough for a mass defederation, it should be a user ban/block not a instance censure.

If the admin team is not enforcing their COC, not policing their users when they go into the fediverse (like hexbear), not responsive to escalations - that would be a good reason for censures or defederation

Someone made a YPTB post, and people were using the censures as a reason the mod behavior was justified, so I started to dig into it and I haven't seen the evidence for the censures and hate.

https://lemmy.world/post/34135214

Can someone show me content on hilariouschaos itself that makes them bad fediverse neighbors?

The censures on fediseer point to what they might do, or behavior on a different lemmy instance - since the instance has been up 2 years its reasonable to expect bad behavior to be observable on hilariouschaos.com itself now. Blank censures are not reasonable. It looks like vibe based censures

I personally think if a group keeps their crazy into !crazythoughts@instance and then goes out into the fediverse acting as good citizens and respecting posted community rules… then thats fine, they are good fediverse neighbors. Hexbear is a example of a bad neighbor, they go out into the fediverse and antagonize others in their home communities.

The published code of conduct looks reasonable, and speaks to points they have been censured for. The admin mod log shows they are actively policing their instance.

  1. Can we update the censures to point to bad neighbor activity from hilariouschaos.com itself - the instance has been up 2 years.
  2. If we can't do 1, can we remove censures that are not relevant in the past 2 years of demonstrated fediverse behavior?

Comments

23

Comments

23