Hey comrades!
My first time formatting text like this, sorry if I messed up!
I need help teaching kids at my new job, teaching at a primary school!
A primary school has hired me as a teacher! Small school in a village that has below 10 kids in each classes. They are struggling to find teachers to teach there (small village, mostly romani kids, challenging environment, etc.), and so they were happy to hire me even though I don’t have my degree yet. I am starting roughly a month from now and I got hired to teach history, ethics, social studies, romani people’s culture and something I can’t really translate, but a dedicated class that is teaching kids about our country’s and people’s history (kinda right wing). I’d be teaching kids all the way from grade 3 to grade 8, their final one in primary school, pleas keep it in mind!
spoiler
Here is what I need help with. I am not expecting you to solve any of them, but I’d appreciate insight, opinions, resources or anything.
I am going to list my 3 topics here:
spoiler
- Anti-communist material.
- The material is clearly and blatantly anti-communist. How do I go about this? Do you think giving context to whatever the books claim is enough? Do you think by trying to provide extra information or saying that other people think about this differently is a good way to not only stay true to myself but be able to make them question things? How would you personally feel about being expected to “teach” these false claims to kids and having to witness the state manipulating history? I am aware this is not your problem, I am just curious. What tools do I have to make them be aware of this type of indoctrination? Do you think it would be risking the job if I’d say at certain claims, that the book is wrong on this? How do I overall navigate this, paying special attention to the fact that they are just kids?
spoiler
- “KIP” (Complex Instruction Program).
- Some christian school in the United Snakes made up a teaching method, which one of my Professor at Uni took and adopted to the hungarian schools. KIP is hated by all teachers I know for various reasons and apparently teachers have mostly stopped doing it in 2018. Nonetheless this is my first time being able to apply it if I want to. The university I am studying at thinks of this as the solution to all problems, which is idealist to say the least. Have any of y’all heard about this? It was made by these people: Article about the program itself and other sources to the papers I could find - 1; 2; 3
Do you have an opinion on this as well as, can you recommend me anything you think could help me teaching these young kids alternative to this (resources, teaching methods, etc)? The reason why I am asking this, because in the mighty EU, the best economic system possible and glorious western democracy, we still have many tens (if not hundreds) of thousands of kids growing up in absolute poverty (just in my country), meaning no food and clothing security. These kids’ families are struggling to feed themselves, can not or only hardly find jobs (if they do it’s a construction site job or the minimal wage jobs the local councils can offer them), and they do not have the ability to clothe themselves at all at times, not to mention not having clothes that fit the changing seasons (meaning wearing T-shirts and shorts in december, it’s not unusual not being able to wash the clothes either, they can wear a fit for a month straight or with little variation until they can afford the cheapest replacements next month). As well as hygene is a problem. Now, I don’t know what we all think about the Maslow pyramid, I guess it has been concluded as outdated by now many times, but I kinda get the part where: when we don’t know what we can have for dinner tomorrow or we run out of money on the first day of getting it to hand, then we can kinda don’t give a flying fuck about studying this or that. So, all in all, I’d be looking for ways to teach them something in this harsh environment they are facing. Sadly, in the parliament, on paper, these people just simply don’t exist. Capitalism hides them and doesn’t acknowledge them/hushes them away. These kids are dubbed as “dumb” and “lazy”, while obviously the white kids are superior to them in all aspects, “hard working” and “smart”. Essentially it’s just plain racism of the whites against romanis. They are blamed for everyting. Everything is their fault, whether in the present or later on in life (while the white kids performance is the fault of the teachers, just to put it in context). Now, I despise saviour complex, so please be realistic. I am just mainly asking because I don’t think frontal work is what they need (or it’s the type of teaching method that can work), it’s more so giving them love, care, and helping them out acquiring skills that they can use in their lives or later in school (which is not the likely scenario - only very small percentages go to high-schools). What I mostly had in mind is just to be human, empathetic, talk a lot with them and guide them to the best of my ability, sadly nobody is expecting anything of them, they are written off as useless and non-human by society and I am afraid, 35 years after we lost socialism, this looks to be an ever increasing trend, towards our minorities (mostly romani).
spoiler
- Balancing life (Work, Party, Personal life, etc.)
- I am autistic. So far I only had administrative jobs. Realistically this job is going to be managable, but I want it to be managable (if I like it) for a long time, this is what I had imagined for myself in life. Now, I am attending university in a half-remote way, meaning some online and some contact lessons. I will have 20 lessons a week as a teacher and possibly spending all-in-all around 40 hours a week there, afaik. How do I not burn out? Family & GF are very supportive, plus the collegues seem to be nice so far. Do you suggest preparing for lessons when I come home or the weekends? What of my party membership, what even can I do to further our cause with all this at hand, how do I make time to participate and do my part? And while my grades are very good now, what if Uni takes a toll?
Overall, I just have noone to turn to with my worries. Some of it are real, some just might be inexperience or lack of confidence yet. If you have any opinions, criticizing or otherwise, please do share, anything to bounce off of helps. Suggestions to make the classes I am going to teach good and enjoyable, or things you think definitely should be taught (for example in the romani class, or other) are welcome as well. You can also tell me what you’d have liked when you were their age and what kinda teacher you’d have enjoyed to be around? I am me, I can’t and don’t want to change that, but if you have something in mind, stories, anything, share!
Thank you for reading it!
While I teach older students, I generally try to tell them the most important question is “why” (and sometimes how). For example, if they are reading state-mandated propaganda, you can ask them “why would X or Y say this?”, or “who benefits from this narrative?”, or “when the book says this, how does it reflect reality?”. Getting them to question the basis of the pseudo-reality they are fed feels like a positive. But since they are young, it needs to be slow and in digestible pieces (I suppose that is just teaching). As such, I would advise against directly saying “the book is wrong here” and rather trying to get the students to reach the conclusion that the book is questionable, by asking the right questions of the material. If you are too direct with your words, then it can easily be seen as subversive. You can easily counter such an argument (if you never explicitly say something is wrong) with saying that you are giving students the tools to think. But it might still be a fine line depending on how the administration feels.
That said, what is the measurement of learning for the students? Is it for a country-wide exam or just for the local area? Or is the only measurement the teacher’s grades? Depending on what happens at the end of the school year, means you could just leave some things out of your lessons entirely and just accidentally not teach the objectionable material. Though, if you have time, you could also teach the full context of an event. Which may lead the students to alternative conclusions. But, generally, students should be led there anyway. We just need to give them the right path to go on.
As for the “Complex Instruction Program” the underlying basis is reasonably sound. But should only be used as one tool in the toolbox. When I try group work it can be very mixed. Some groups will do excellent work because they are motivated by the assignment, while others depend on one or two students to do the majority of the task. It can be slightly better if the students are given “jobs” to perform during group work, like “leader” (the person who makes sure everyone does work) or “reporter” (they would report how many questions everyone asked, or summarize what happened in the group). There have also even been some students who don’t want to do group work at all. But so long as the assignment is completed, it doesn’t really matter. Overall, I’d probably recommend group work for large projects and consider it for smaller work if students could all feel like they can contribute.
At least for my students, group work on smaller worksheets (two students working on the same assignment and only handing in one copy) doesn’t particularly work because they largely divide up the questions and don’t bother actually talking to each other and discussing the answers. This is because of their mindset that the only thing that matters is the end-product, rather than the learning they should be doing. But that’s because they’ve been learning that way for the last decade. Hopefully if you get students earlier, they won’t have so much of that style of thinking pushed into them.
Another thing to consider is how used to group work the students are and how much training the teacher has to do for them to complete whatever task they have. In general, tasks shouldn’t be too hard or too easy and broken down in enough steps where it is able to be completed. For example, on larger assignments I give many different due dates (sometimes upwards of five or six) to students and expect to check in on them daily to note their progress. Otherwise many would wait until the last day to work on and submit their less than mediocre quality final draft. Which somewhat defeats the purpose of learning to create something of their own.
As for specific books, there are two I can highly recommend. If you read nothing else, read these two.
Powerful teaching: unleash the science of learning P. Argawal & P. Bain
Make it stick: the science of effective learning P. Brown, H. Roedigger, & M. Mcdaniel
What I mostly had in mind is just to be human, empathetic, talk a lot with them and guide them to the best of my ability
The above is definitely an important part of being a teacher. And since you are teaching social studies and other humanities; reading, writing, and thinking are important skills that students need in society and you can always emphasize those skills in your lessons and in conversations with students.
These kids are dubbed as “dumb” and “lazy”, while obviously the white kids are superior to them in all aspects, “hard working” and “smart”.
Here, you are hitting a little bit on labeling theory, which is a sociological idea that if you give someone a label it can be a self-fulfilling prophecy for both the giver and receiver. Which I do find has some basis in reality, both in the way I treat students and in the way students treat themselves. Though I get them a little late, so it’s much harder to make a dent in a negative mindset. With that in mind, I tend to treat students with as much empathy as possible, which seems to work well with most of them.
For the final topic, I have some bad news. The first time you teach it’s a lot of work. There’s a lot of preparation to be done and you might find you will have less time to do things that you want to do. Especially if you are also doing university classes. Definitely think about what you should prioritize (for me, it’s mostly resting after a long day of masking as a teacher). As for the act of preparation, it would be best to have a specific time and place where you are able to solely do planning. If you have a quiet place at school, then I would suggest doing it there. As it’s much better for work-life balance and your general sanity. 20 lessons may not seem like a lot, but it can take a while to prepare a good lesson, as well as develop your delivery skills, and trying to assess whether the students have learned anything.
It would be easier if you had a basic template to work with for each lesson, so you could effectively plug-and-play the new content. For example:
- the first 5 minutes is a review quiz of last time’s lesson
- then you spend 10 minutes on introducing new terms and concepts
- then you spend 20 minutes talking about the topic (a smaller amount of time for younger students)
- then the students do something with that topic for some amount of time
- then the students do some task for reviewing the material
- then a small preview of the lesson for next time
But the basic idea should be to keep the students active and doing something, especially the younger ones. Something like Total Physical Response where the students have to physically do something in the class will help.
Anyway, there are a lot of questions in your post. If you feel I didn’t cover something that you really want an answer to, please ask again. Or if you have other questions, I’m also happy to help with them!
Excellent answer! Hats off, the effort you put in this comment is humbling!
I need to coordinate all aspects of this adventure to optimize my chances to tackle this whole thing successfully. So, allow me to take my time with this, gather my thoughts and plan things ahead. I might reach out to you, I don’t yet know, however I am very thankful for you opening up that door to me in your comment. Thanks for taking the time to write this!
While I have spent over a decade of teaching, the most enjoyable years were those where I could help other teachers. Anyway, take your time and I’ll be somewhere on the internet. And I’ll leave you with another tip: the most useful skill to learn might be reflection on what went well and why, and what went wrong and why.
Pedagogy of the Oppressed is a classic you may find of some use. Best of luck, comrade!
Looks like they took it down. You might try here: https://annas-archive.org/search?q=Pedagogy+of+the+Oppressed
Ugh, thanks for catching that!
Thank you both, I have started reading it immediately!
o7
Damn, this is a lot to read. You’re based in Hungary, right?
Also, as a fellow Autistic, I suggest being careful with how you air your opinions and maybe let the kids decide while presenting them the facts of the matter.
Don’t try to browbeat them into the correct opinions or truth; you want to not traumatize anyone accidentally. Definitely clamp down on bullying.
When I was a kid, I was called racist epithets and bullied a lot.
Well, sure, I’m sorry if it is too much, I tried to cut down the amount, but I felt like I need to provide context for the message to be understood properly.
The formatting looks all good in a browser (mobile, pc), Jerboa however did not seem to present it the way I’d have liked it to present.
I will try my best to implement your advices, thank you!
Ofc!
I don’t have resources or sources that could help you but I wish you a lot of success as a school teacher! That is a splendid job and a very much needed one!
Thank you, I appreciate it! This is a big challange ahead, most definitely.