- cross-posted to:
- ukraine@sopuli.xyz
- news@lemmy.world
- world@quokk.au
- cross-posted to:
- ukraine@sopuli.xyz
- news@lemmy.world
- world@quokk.au
Ukraine’s allies met Thursday for a “Coalition of the Willing” summit in Berlin with President Volodymyr Zelensky to stress solid wartime support for Kyiv and to push for a European role in any future peace talks.
Co-hosting the talks with the leaders of Germany and the UK, French President Emmanuel Macron called on Ukraine’s allies to do the “maximum” to deliver the air defence systems it needs, and urged them to “reopen the question” of Ukraine’s NATO membership.
…
“Faced with the maximalist nature of the Russian position, I believe we need to reopen the question of Ukraine’s accession to NATO,” Macron said in Berlin.
“Everyone who has the capacity to provide the means to defend and protect Ukrainian citizens must do so now,” he insisted, adding the priority was to deploy anti-missile systems and interceptors.
…
The new vessels – built in the UK - will strengthen Ukraine’s ability to defend the Black Sea, protect its coastline and secure vital trade routes, applying greater pressure on Putin.
UK and Norway will also deepen cooperation on artificial intelligence, including on defensive AI for the battlefield.
…
EU has a defense clause. It’s stronger than the NATO clause. EU can do this without the US right now. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/EN/legal-content/glossary/mutual-defence-clause.html
NATO understandably requires unanimous approval and, I think, no territorial disputes. Ukraine joining NATO now is never happening.
This is political theatre. Aiming for NATO over EU defense clause just shows the EU dependence on the US military. Fix that first, then talk.
This is political theatre. Aiming for NATO over EU defense clause just shows the EU dependence on the US military. Fix that first, then talk.
That would open the question what transatlantic allyship actually means.
Even if NATO is healthy and strong, there’s no reason to wait for a full NATO consensus. Hell, France can sign a treaty right now with Ukraine by itself. EU could too.
My point is less about the state of the US or if the US will back NATO, but rather, countries can build the alliance right now. They could each sign a NATO-adjacent treaty as a bridge agreement until full NATO membership.
That they don’t is a bit telling of the issue.
Why is Nato membership needed? They can escalate the war right now if they want. Ukraine Nato membership doesn’t change anything about international law.
The new vessels – built in the UK - will strengthen Ukraine’s ability to defend the Black Sea
How do they get them through the Bosphorus?
Because attacking a NATO country means (risking) war with the US.
And as opposed to the EU, the US is very much feared by self proclaimed strongmen such as Putin or even Xi.
Only on paper
So France wants to trick the US into fighting?
The US has to accept the membership of Ukraine first while they know that it means fighting.
Iran, Venezuela, if the US wants to fight Russia they can do it at any moment. They don’t need Ukraine to be part of Nato. Why waste the time for Nato membership procedures if they can fight right now?
So France wants to trick the US into fighting?
No.
France wants to make sure that Russia will not have any appetite left to attack Ukraine again. The ultimate way to do so is to have Ukraine in the same defence alliance as the US.
Iran, Venezuela, if the US wants to fight Russia they can do it at any moment. They don’t need Ukraine to be part of Nato. Why waste the time for Nato membership procedures if they can fight right now?
You’re jumping to wrong conclusions because you think this is about attacking Russia, while it really is about defending Ukraine from Russian aggression.
not have any appetite left to attack Ukraine again
How should that work out? Ukraine is at war. Article 5 is activated the moment Ukraine becomes a member.
Instead of accepting Ukraine as a member, the US could as well tell Russia that the US will enter the war if Russia hasn’t fully retreated by the end of the month. Why waste time with the membership process?
Besides, the US gave assurances, not guarantees in Budapest. The US didn’t have and my guess is won’t have any intentions to fight this war.
How should that work out? Ukraine is at war.
Obviously, the whole talk about NATO membership is for the time after the war.
But that must be a given. Russia offered peace for the conquered territories and no Nato membership. To leave Ukraine without it, especially if they have to cecede territory would be cruel.
Russia offered peace for the conquered territories and no Nato membership.
Wrong.
Russia wants territories it fails to have conquered for more than four years. Also, no foreign troops on Ukrainian soil whatsoever, and NATO has to effectively abandon all members since 1997. It is a proposal as dumb and pointless as the idea of “quickly conquering” Ukraine in 2022.
Russia also agreed to respect Ukraine’s souvereignty and borders. Putin himself even said that Ukraine joining NATO would be a souvereign decision of Ukraine and would not deteriorate relations between the two countries. Russia said it won’t invade Ukraine and any reports about it are merely hysterical press from the evil West.
Or in other words: Russia is talking a lot of bullshit and it is always best to ignore this insubstantial noise and rather look at their actions. We won’t let the future of Ukraine and Europe be dictated from Moscow - even if their crony from Mar-a-Lago tries to force us.


