This piece has been written by Preston Lim, assistant professor at Queen’s University’s Faculty of Law.

Archived link

…

The Carney government no doubt views increased commerce with China as a vital element of its trade diversification strategy and a necessary response to strained ties with the United States. But the Prime Minister would do well to remember that increased economic integration with China is far from a risk-free proposition. His predecessor learned this the hard way – and Justin Trudeau’s failures reveal the potential landmines that could derail Mr. Carney’s own China strategy.

By this point, Canadians should well understand that increased trade with China also means increased vulnerability. Beijing has habitually applied economic coercion against countries that do not toe the party line. In 2019, several months after Canadian authorities arrested Huawei CFO Meng Wanzhou in connection with a U.S. extradition warrant, Beijing suspended Canadian pork and beef imports. Last year, after Canada imposed a tariff on Chinese electric vehicles and steel and aluminum products, China retaliated by placing bruising tariffs on a range of Canadian natural products.

…

Canada is far from the only country to have been on the receiving end of Chinese economic coercion. After the Australian government called for an inquiry into the origins of COVID-19, the Chinese government implemented trade restrictions on a range of Australian imports. China has a track record of weaponizing economic ties with foreign states, and it would be jejune to pretend that China now plays by the rules of the international trade order. Increased trade with Canada presents Beijing with leverage.

…

The Prime Minister’s China push could also conflict with his efforts to diversify trade, specifically in terms of drawing closer to other states in the Indo-Pacific region … Mr. Carney is set to sign a free-trade agreement with Filipino President “Bongbong” Marcos in 2027. This anticipated deal makes tremendous sense, due to the Philippines’ economic potential and status as a democracy.

Yet it is no secret that the Philippines and China remain mired in geopolitical conflict over the illegal incursions of Chinese fishing and coast guard vessels into Filipino waters. In recent years, Ottawa has shared satellite data with Manila on these Chinese incursions through the Dark Vessel Detection program. What if Beijing threatens to slap tariffs on Canadian exports unless Ottawa halts this data-sharing?

…

The Prime Minister’s stated commitment to Canadian sovereignty should logically translate into sharp restrictions on inbound Chinese investment, but it is difficult to see how the Prime Minister will be able to court meaningful Chinese investment unless his government softens the national security review process under the Investment Canada Act. Under that process, Ottawa may consider factors such as the “potential of the investment to undermine Canada’s economic security” when reviewing a covered investment. The government cannot pursue aggressive engagement while also keeping robust national security safeguards in place.

…

Mr. Carney’s China strategy risks resembling that of his predecessor, Justin Trudeau. For much of his premiership, Mr. Trudeau prioritized economic engagement with Beijing; as late as 2018, he was still discussing the possibility of a bilateral free trade agreement. But in the aftermath of the arbitrary arrests of Michael Kovrig and Michael Spavor, it seemed incredible that he could have ever believed China to be an appropriate economic partner.

We are a world away from 2018, of course, and Mr. Carney does not have the luxury of easy strategic choices. And yet, the danger remains that Mr. Carney is taking China as he wishes it to be, not as it is. Time will tell if his own China dream will crash on the shoals of reality.

  • rumimevlevi@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    18 minutes ago

    What I am really worried about is Carney supporting genocide in Gaza, supporting genocide in Sudan, supporting genocide in Saudi Arabia, supporting the war of aggression on Iran, contributing to the destruction of the environment, and not respecting First Nations rights.

  • nyan@lemmy.cafe
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    1 hour ago

    Opinion: This editorial is a waste of electrons, repeating things that everyone (including Carney, and, I suspect, even Trudeau) already knows. I am very tired of these “Oh noes! 1% more of our trade might be with China next year! And the PM is trying to squeeze investment money out of them! The sky is falling!!!1!” articles, laced with what-ifs and other insubstantial fear-mongering. Yes, dealing with China is dangerous. For much the same reason that dealing with the US is dangerous (except that China is lawful evil and the US, at the moment, is more chaotic evil). This country has a lot of experience when it comes to waltzing with elephants that don’t necessarily have our good in mind.

  • ScottyOP
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    3 hours ago

    Margaret McCuaig-Johnston, a senior fellow at the University of Ottawa and a leading expert on Canada-China relations, said Carney’s talk of greater Chinese involvement in the Canadian auto industry may be a bargaining move as talks with the U.S. stretch on.

    “That, in my view, would be encouraging. If it’s a bargaining chip, it can be dropped,” McCuaig-Johnston said …

    “If it’s an offer to China to open up our manufacturing to them, that’s got a lot of concerns. They don’t want to use Canadian parts, they don’t want to follow Canadian labour standards … and they don’t want technology transfer (to Canadian companies)" …

    McCuaig-Johnston added that those factors were the “guardrails” the federal government often talks about when it comes to protecting Canada’s auto sector while allowing greater Chinese investment., but says what those protections are is not exactly clear.

    This leads to another issue beyond economic relationship:

    Carney also said he would raise the issue of Chinese foreign interference in Canadian political affairs with Xi.

    The Canadian intelligence community has repeatedly warned that China, among other countries, has attempted to covertly interfere in Canadian politics, as well as engage in transnational repression against Chinese diaspora groups living Canada.