I think its possible to preserve the state with a socialist government without it withering it away. Pls answer in simple english, it would be helpful for me to understand.
The state and government are separate, the state refers to the elements of society that exist to protect the ruling class. When all production and distribution is eventually collectivized, there is no class, so no need for a state. The idea of a preservation of state means production and distribution are not actually advancing to the point where they must be collectivized, which either means you are frozen in time or under serious economic strangulation.
As long as you have small producers, you will have class distinctions, and as such you will need a state to enforce the rule of the proletarian class above other classes. As you develop the forces of production and the small producers necessarily wither away, then so do class distinctions, and if class distinctions ever get to the point of effectively having disappeared, then there would no longer be a role for the state as such.
Note that the state in the Marxist definition does not mean administration or centralization. It just means the apparatus of class oppression, and so it is that which Marxists argue would wither away in a classless society. The economic basis is still centralized production and there is still an administration of things. This is why it is nonsense, how some people claim, that Marxism and anarchism has the same “end goal” because they’re both stateless. What anarchists and Marxists mean by the state are not the same things, and so the “end goal” is not the same.
Within Marxism-Leninism, the state has a specific, technical meaning. It don’t simply mean a government. It means a government that exists to enforce the rule of one class over other classes.
Under capitalism, the state enforces bourgeois rule over the proletariat.
Under socialism, the state enforces proletarian rule of the bourgeoisie.
Once a socialist state eventually becomes fully proletarianized, there are no other classes left to suppress; it has effectively become classless. That is the point at which the state has withered away, and communism has been achieved.
There probably will be a government under communism: Just not as pervasive (no need to military to invade countries for capitalist reasons).
I think I read about that in “ABC of Communism” by Preobrazhensky and Bukharin (has anyone else read that?).
You’re thinking of communism.
A stateless classless society is Communism. In order to achieve it, first a socialist state must be established (where there is a dictatorship of the proletariat, instead of a dictatorship of capital). The socialist state must then create the needed material conditions for communism. But, for communism to exist, the socialist state must wither away.
Priciples of Communism by Friedrich Engels explains this best.
Before I can answer (which I am most willing to do), I need to understand what you mean by “state” and “stateless” exactly. Because in philosophical terms, these words can mean very different things from what regular people have in mind.
It’s also important to be able to tell apart socialism from communism, so which one specifically are you asking about? Or are the two interchangeable for you?
Your question is important, because a lot of leftists have a similar question, but are too afraid to ask it I think, which leads to confusion and infighting.







