If you get stormed by 10 Al Qaeda freedom fighters and one is a US citizen, do you try to shoot that one in the leg to allow him his fair day in court?
Or do you spray all ten of them left to right and then left again because, you know, that’s what you do in a war
The thing is, he wasn’t the first US citizen to be killed by the US government. It’s just that in times prior to this the government had to provide credible evidence that the person was an immediate threat.
The Obama administration refused to elaborate on why they considered this person as an immediate threat. They just labeled him a terrorist and then sent the drone.
I would simply not get stormed by 10 Al Qaida freedom fighters by not going to their country in the first place.
Also, can we just take a moment to appreciate how wildly you’re distorting this? He was not killed “storming” someone with 9 other people. There was no physical danger. He was killed by an unmanned drone, by someone probably sitting in an air conditioned room on the other side of the world. And this was in Yemen, a country we weren’t even at war with. So when you say, “that’s what you do in war,” apparently, it’s also what you think we should do in peace.
What would you say if Yemen launched a drone strike in the US, claiming that the US was harboring a terrorist? That cool with you? Is that just “what you do in not-war?”
Completely ridiculous. What you’re saying right now is exactly what actual authoritarianism looks like.
Motherfucker, did you hear how many people were talking about attacking Middle Eastern civilians across the US during that period? How many Americans talked about nuking the Middle East, turning the sand to glass, exterminating the entire region? Do you think that sounded peaceful to them? Do you think, then, that Al Qaida was justified in attacking civilian targets if said civilian had said something like that? If that’s what it takes, the majority of the US population would have been valid military targets. What a load of nonsense.
But no, it only goes one way. The US can set the rules that everyone else in the world has to obey. The US doesn’t have to obey anybody else’s rules. Why? Because the US has power and authority. Authority that you believe in asserting over the entire rest of the world. Because you are an imperialist.
That’s not even mentioning the fact that you completely ignored my entire argument. Even if it was justified to kill him in this case, it still involved giving the executive unilateral power to execute any person anywhere in the world, with zero oversight or accountability. Either you believe the executive should have that power, or you don’t. You don’t get to support it having that power only in the cases where you agree with the decisions the executive made. If you think you should have some say over such decisions, then you should support those decisions being democratically accountable.
If you get stormed by 10 Al Qaeda freedom fighters and one is a US citizen, do you try to shoot that one in the leg to allow him his fair day in court?
Or do you spray all ten of them left to right and then left again because, you know, that’s what you do in a war
The thing is, he wasn’t the first US citizen to be killed by the US government. It’s just that in times prior to this the government had to provide credible evidence that the person was an immediate threat.
The Obama administration refused to elaborate on why they considered this person as an immediate threat. They just labeled him a terrorist and then sent the drone.
They elaborated he was recruiting people and coordinating attacks. You might not consider that an ‘imminent threat’ but others sure would.
I would simply not get stormed by 10 Al Qaida freedom fighters by not going to their country in the first place.
Also, can we just take a moment to appreciate how wildly you’re distorting this? He was not killed “storming” someone with 9 other people. There was no physical danger. He was killed by an unmanned drone, by someone probably sitting in an air conditioned room on the other side of the world. And this was in Yemen, a country we weren’t even at war with. So when you say, “that’s what you do in war,” apparently, it’s also what you think we should do in peace.
What would you say if Yemen launched a drone strike in the US, claiming that the US was harboring a terrorist? That cool with you? Is that just “what you do in not-war?”
Completely ridiculous. What you’re saying right now is exactly what actual authoritarianism looks like.
He was calling for people to attack US civilians. Does that sound peaceful to you? Would it have sounded peaceful to Obama?
Motherfucker, did you hear how many people were talking about attacking Middle Eastern civilians across the US during that period? How many Americans talked about nuking the Middle East, turning the sand to glass, exterminating the entire region? Do you think that sounded peaceful to them? Do you think, then, that Al Qaida was justified in attacking civilian targets if said civilian had said something like that? If that’s what it takes, the majority of the US population would have been valid military targets. What a load of nonsense.
But no, it only goes one way. The US can set the rules that everyone else in the world has to obey. The US doesn’t have to obey anybody else’s rules. Why? Because the US has power and authority. Authority that you believe in asserting over the entire rest of the world. Because you are an imperialist.
That’s not even mentioning the fact that you completely ignored my entire argument. Even if it was justified to kill him in this case, it still involved giving the executive unilateral power to execute any person anywhere in the world, with zero oversight or accountability. Either you believe the executive should have that power, or you don’t. You don’t get to support it having that power only in the cases where you agree with the decisions the executive made. If you think you should have some say over such decisions, then you should support those decisions being democratically accountable.
“Motherfucker”?
Yes, motherfucker. It’s generally how I refer to people who say ridiculous bullshit.