Mit einem neuen Investitionsschutzgesetz will Bundesinnenminister Alexander Dobrindt (CSU) die Voraussetzungen für Vergesellschaftungen genau regeln und damit erschweren. Mit dem Gesetz werde die Bundesregierung deutlich machen, „dass willkürlicher linker Vergesellschaftungs-Fetisch mit dem Grundgesetz nicht vereinbar ist“, sagte Dobrindt der „Bild"-Zeitung laut Mitteilung vom Sonntag.

  • gusgalarnyk@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    21 days ago

    Idk who’s arguing society is more prosperous in the housing department now than it was 60 years ago. You’re conflating a very large set of metrics with one paired correlation. I would argue housing is getting undeniably worse for most people as a percentage of their net income and the quality that amount of money buys them.

    So even if you include the rates of home ownership, you need to account for the size of those homes, the quality of those homes, the debt those people are in (as you said, “house poor”). Ownership is not the single end-all metric, the real metric would be the power people have over their housing which I have no doubt is at a nearly all time low - hence why everyone rents, why those rentals are worse and smaller than they’ve ever been, and more expensive then they’ve ever been.

    I’m explicitly arguing that housing should not be an investment. Housing should be affordable, that is a fundamental goal of society. We don’t have stocks in food such that food should get more expensive every year. You might have stock in a company that makes food, but not in bananas because they’re inherently perishable - exactly like housing.

    Everyone should be wealthy, I can agree with that. And you’re right, it doesn’t have to be a house. But they have to be sufficiently wealthy that they have direct and meaningful control over their housing situation or it will breed contempt with the system - as we’re seeing around the world in the developed countries.

    I’m not talking about the right to change their housing, I’m talking about the power to which you e separated as the right and the liquidity. I’m talking about the combined power, so if you tell me they have one but not the other than for my intents and purposes they fail the necessary check that demonstrates if a society is working or not.

    • brainwashed@feddit.org
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      21 days ago

      I am arguing that owning one’s house does not at all tell you anything about the overall net worth or the quality of the dwelling. Think shack owners in some favela. Conflating the two leads to bad policies. See the US financial crisis where everyone could lend more than they could afford, which could in theory be beneficial but lead to a real estate bubble.

      And yes, wealth gives options and is desirable, probably also lessens contempt. Destroying property values by taxing it arbitrarily does cheapen the property, just doesn’t make it more efffordable for the lower half of the income distribution.