Everspace is very cool - it's a rouge like where you upgrade your ship as you progress with very unique skills and different branches.I'm also in love with Cosmoteer - 2D game where you can build, rebuild, salvage enemy ships, eventually create a small fleet and experiment a lot with different designs.
Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons - pretty cool as you can play on 1 controller.Star Wars Battlefront 2 (OG) - have awesome memories with it.Earth Defence Force 4 or 5 - over the top bug extermination and built in split screen even on PC.Last thing I can recommend is Saints Row 2, 3 and 4 (especially 3) - but you need something like Nucleus to play on the same device.
Cthulhu, hear me out - if it happens it would automatically mean he's real and will be on his way to end all the Earth's current troubles.