When we vote in Canada we always had to show ID. There are also many combinations of ways to prove your identity. Drivers license, a bill, student card, you can bring a friend that knows you and they vouch etc.
Identification is good, just need to allow more ways to identify yourself.
Here's a video I saw from an Australian YouTuber that voiced his criticisms.
https://youtu.be/bfHx4CfKFqQ
The main 2 critiques I took away from:
But people have different issues with it. Just one person's view point.
It does paint a deeper problem with the US news system.