I'm a cat person who appreciates dogs, and this is spot on. Cats may demand food, but you can wait out a tantrum.
The fear of having to potentially clean up an accidental means I'm up no matter what if the dogs are waking me up. I don't like cleaning up these messes, and the dogs actively look like they feel bad watching me do it. We're all having a bad time.
I'd much rather have a sleepy, half-hearted argument with my cats than worry I'm depriving one of the dogs of going outside if they're having an emergency. Apples to oranges.
Yeah, no. If you read my post, I was referencing dogs having an emergency (diarrhea, if I need to clarify further) and needing to go out. This isn't an imaginary situation, and every dog owner I know has experienced having to clean up a mess because their well trained dog simply couldn't hold it. It's not a criticism, as anyone with stomach issues that doesn't have access to a bathroom would have an accident, too. Cats rarely have this issue, because they have an indoor bathroom.
I don't know why you took my post as idealizing cats and criticizing dogs, but that's absolutely not the point of what I said.