It is once again, again, time to collect more suggestions. As usual, texts should be Marxist theory of some kind and will be selected (if appropriate) roughly based on number of upvotes.

For those who aren’t interested in participating, is there any particular reason other than the time commitment? Leave your answer in the comments and don’t forget to like and subscribe

Avoid suggesting the following texts since they’ve already been used:

Previous texts

Marx:

Engels:

Lenin:

Stalin:

Mao:

Other:

  • DornerStan@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    2 months ago

    That’s basically all there is to it, really. Marx wrote to the German workers in like 1850 something like “under no pretexts should the arms be given up, any attempt to do so should be frustrated by force”. And people take it to mean “In 2026 Marxists should use their [non-existent] political capital to oppose magazine capacity limits”. I’m representing the argument really uncharitably here, there’s gradients of course, and perhaps it’s a useful quote to try and break non-Marxists from their misconceptions about communism. But it’s clear from the context that Marx wasn’t trying to write an 11th commandment.

    Revolutionary defeatism, like refusing to fight in inter-imperialist wars, instead using them as an opportunity to seize power. Relevant in the context of multiple imperial powers vying for control like in WWI, less so in wars of extermination and imperial conquest like WWII and forward. It’ll commonly be invoked against Iran, or even Palestine in fringe cases, or historically to argue against the Chinese communists temporarily uniting with the nationalists to fight the Japanese.

    • LeninZedong@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      2 months ago

      But you could argue that the circumstances might have justified a fight against the Japanese first (though I do not know the exact circumstances behind the war, and I know that Japan had a really nasty history with how they treated Chinese people), so calling it revolutionary defeatism seems strange. I have heard of such a thing when someone (probably Lenin) talked about WWI and how all countries (besides Russia and Serbia, I think?) had their communist parties fight for their motherland rather than seizing opportunities or whatever.