alt text

A 4 panel comic. In the first panel, a character stands on a cliff, addressing an audience, and says “trans kids should not get puberty blockers”. In the second panel, the audience, armed and labeled “cis people”, looks content. In the third panel, the character on the cliff says “they should get hrt so they can go through the right puberty at the same time as their cis peers”. In the fourth panel, the audience, still labeled “cis people”, looks angry at the character.

if you’re cis and seeing this: keep your concern trolling to yourself.

  • carin_heron@lemmy.blahaj.zone
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    3 days ago

    That’s very kind of you, I’m glad to hear that my comment was helpful. There’s a lot of other things to touch on here.

    That’s a very good question regarding what I was actually attributing the violent acts to. So, when I say that these practices are violent, it is true that individuals are carrying out those practices and play a role in reproducing their use in our medical/educational/legal institutions, but it is important to remember that it the systemic nature of this violence that is so problematic. The very construction of gender within an imperialistic, capitalist system is oriented around property and the systems of power that controls the ownership of property, which means that the practice of refusing transness’ existence as anything other than – at best – a medical disorder has been in use for the past three centuries at least. This is because, in order to secure the generational ownership of property and concentrate the right of ownership into an arbitrary, privileged group, women’s bodies are objectified for their reproductive capacity, and ownership over that reproductive capacity was legally secured for white men. If those bodies are for anything other than reproducing this way of life through control over the children who inherit property and privilege, then they are a threat to the very foundation of this system.

    Consequently, doctors come into their profession after a lifetime of socialization which primes them to devalue trans people through an understanding of gender as some natural, biological binary that is made synonymous with “sex.” So, they do not need to directly and overtly commit violence or malpractice against trans people to either be part of an institution that is fundamentally opposed to the existence of trans people, or to hold some internalized perceptions of trans people that could even subconsciously effect the care that their patients get. Even if they’re someone who is consciously empathetic toward trans people, whatever actions or beliefs that are afforded to them are inevitably mediated through a system that is fundamentally opposed to the existence of transness, and has only recently capitulated a degree of recognition after a sufficient amount of disruption.

    When trans people are refused the language and understanding to interpret how this system injurs them and why, it disorients them not only in relation to themselves and their bodies, but the entire world around them as well. The doctors who did not accurately diagnose dysphoria because of their own lack of language and knowledge are by no means personally liable for the systemic violence they are a part of, but the fact remains that it is a form of violence which they participate in, willfully or otherwise. The system is the perpetrator of that violence, and individuals only have so much power afforded to them to comply with or challenge that system. I’ve had a similar experience where, if they simply did not understand gender and sex as synonymous, and attributed diagnostical values to symptoms along the line of sex, then I would have very well received treatment for ADHD and PTSD much earlier in my life.

    As far as the physical changes of transition goes, those are all such valid concerns to have. I wasn’t quite as hairy as you were, but I was exceptional at performing masculinity as well. Big, strong, and I always better at like, styling masculinity in my outfits and appearance. I also happen to be more masc as a woman than a man, because men don’t actually own the elements of masculinity that I’ve always liked anyway. If you found that you enjoyed those elements of masculinity, you don’t have to let go of them until you want to, and you may very well find that you just outgrew them too. For years before I transitioned, I often worried whether it was just better to continue being a masculine man, or masc non-binary, or whatever, just because I’m more comfortable being better at masc performativity in many ways. And it’s true, a lot of femme performative maintenance is extra labour, and the bar for men’s style and appearance is so much lower.

    On that note, I can honestly say that I never cared about my body until I started transitioning. I tried to many times, but I honestly could never look at it and feel like it was something I loved. Of course, I have injuries and health issues to manage as a consequence of not treating it well, and that I didn’t treat it well was a barrier to a more immediate feeling of euphoria once I started transitioning. The first time I saw myself in the mirror and liked what I saw, I realized why it wasn’t just a lack of will or ability to take care of it before. I seriously do not know whether my experience with derealization is relatable to most trans women, but I did not even realize I had it until well after I had started transitioning. It was like focusing my eyes for the first time. I think these are very reasonable and valid concerns to have, especially since you understand the gravity of taking on health complications as you age. My experience has taught me that I would have seriously had worse health outcomes if I simply spent all my effort on trying to resolve those health issues (including substance abuse).

    I have to admit that I did not take on much of a health risk by starting HRT besides the standard increase in cardiovascular complications that simply comes with estrogen, but I could have easily taken on more with the relief that it has provided. Like, I enjoy working out now, and I can’t emphasize enough what a miracle that is.

    I really don’t know what’s best for you, and please, do not feel as though your experiences have to be similar to mine to feel valid as a trans woman or whatever gender identity you arrive at that feels right for you. Every concern you’ve mentioned here is completely valid and relatable, so I do hope that this helps make the right choice for you much clearer.