Sure, and when it’s about your hypothetical example of someone not doing evil things I certainly agree
Because using it on this man who may have been doing “evil” things, opens the window on it being used on perfectly innocent people. My point is that a president should not have the ability to do it all.
But why pick this case, where it certainly worked as advertized?
You think the government killing one questionably “evil” man validates the killing of two innocent children? The government should not be able to extrajudicially murder any of its own civilians. I really don’t see how you cannot fathom the potential harm that can come about by allowing the government this kind of power.
So does that mean that the murdering of any other civilians is implicitly allowed?
Explicit targeting of civilians during war is still illegal, though there is not often a reliable recourse of action. That doesn’t mean there shouldn’t be, or that two wrongs make a right.
Under international law, members of an armed group are not considered civilians while they are participating in hostilities.
That being said there are several drone strikes of declared “terrorist” that I would consider illegal, especially when there are collateral casualties involving civilians.
Because using it on this man who may have been doing “evil” things, opens the window on it being used on perfectly innocent people. My point is that a president should not have the ability to do it all.
You think the government killing one questionably “evil” man validates the killing of two innocent children? The government should not be able to extrajudicially murder any of its own civilians. I really don’t see how you cannot fathom the potential harm that can come about by allowing the government this kind of power.
Why would they be allowed to murder any other civilians, but not their own?
Never claimed that they should? Just that the murdering of your own civilians without due process is expressly prohibited by the constitution.
So does that mean that the murdering of any other civilians is implicitly allowed?
Is that distinction something you agree with?
Explicit targeting of civilians during war is still illegal, though there is not often a reliable recourse of action. That doesn’t mean there shouldn’t be, or that two wrongs make a right.
So would you say that the murder of all the other Al Qaeda dudes and dudettes on Obama’s orders were also illegal?
Under international law, members of an armed group are not considered civilians while they are participating in hostilities.
That being said there are several drone strikes of declared “terrorist” that I would consider illegal, especially when there are collateral casualties involving civilians.